Research Article |
|
Corresponding author: Anna A. Namyatova ( anna.namyatova@gmail.com ) Academic editor: Andreas Zwick
© 2026 Anna A. Namyatova, Polina A. Dzhelali, Darya S. Bolshakova.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Namyatova AA, Dzhelali PA, Bolshakova DS (2026) Integrative delimitation of Apolygus (Insecta: Heteroptera: Miridae: Mirinae) species known from Russia with the emphasis on Apolygus lucorum and Apolygus spinolae having trans-Palearctic distribution. Arthropod Systematics & Phylogeny 84: 47-93. https://doi.org/10.3897/asp.84.e161376
|
Apolygus (Insecta: Heteroptera: Miridae: Mirinae) is a large and taxonomically challenging trans-Palearctic genus comprising 74 species, and it has never been revised. The greatest diversity of this genus occurs in Asia, and 15 species have been recorded from Russia. Among them, Apolygus limbatus, Apolygus lucorum, and Apolygus spinolae are trans-Palearctic, and A. lucorum and A. spinolae are economically important as pests. Previous studies have shown that A. lucorum and A. spinolae are very similar in morphology and that the barcoding region might not be suitable for their identification. In this study a revision of the Apolygus representatives inhabiting Russia is provided based on morphological and molecular data. Mitochondrial (COI and 16S rRNA) and nuclear markers (ITS1 and 28S3 rRNA) were used for phylogenetic analyses and automatic species delimitation methods were applied. Apolygus lucorum, A. malaisei, A. nigronasutus, A. nigrovirens were treated as junior synonyms of A. spinolae because morphological and molecular data did not show differences between those species. Apolygus shikotan sp. nov. was described as new to science. Morphological data and the COI phylogeny show that A. limbatus might represent two separate species. However, additional specimens and nuclear markers for both groups are needed to test this hypothesis. The synonymy of A. syringae with A. hilaris was supported based on the morphological data. Apolygus gotorum and A. subhilaris are reported from Russia for the first time. The nuclear marker ITS1 is the most reliable marker for species delimitation and identification of Apolygus species.
Palearctic, widespread species, species delimitation, integrative taxonomy, morphology, molecular phylogenetics
There is a growing number of studies addressing taxonomic problems using molecular data, which can help to reveal cryptic species and to test the status of species and subspecies described based on color and small morphological differences. This integrative approach is especially important for widespread species with considerable intraspecific variation (
The family Miridae, or plant bugs, is distributed worldwide and it is also diverse in the Palearctic (>2800 species) (
Apolygus representatives are distributed from the boreal to tropical zones of Eurasia. Among them, Apolygus lucorum (Meyer-Dür, 1843), A. limbatus (Fallén, 1807) and A. spinolae (Meyer-Dür, 1841) are trans-Palearctic, and A. lucorum is considered invasive in North America (
Currently, there are 15 Apolygus species known from Russia: Apolygus adustus (Jakovlev, 1876), A. fraxinicola (Kerzhner, 1988), A. furvus (Kerzhner, 1972), A. hilaris (Horváth, 1905), A. infamis (Kerzhner, 1977), A. limbatus (Fallen, 1807), A. lucorum, A. maackiae (Kulik, 1965), A. malaisei, A. nigronasutus, A. nigrovirens, A. spinolae, A. subpulchellus (Kerzhner, 1988), A. syringae (Kerzhner, 1988), and A. watajii Yasunaga & Yasunaga, 2000 (
The identification of Apolygus has applied importance, because both, A. lucorum and A. spinolae, are considered serious pests of different crops, including cotton, vegetables and fruit trees in Asia (e.g.,
Specimens from the historical collection of the Zoological Institute of the Russian Academy of Sciences, St Petersburg, Russia (ZIN) and recently collected material were examined. Specimens were initially identified using the original descriptions and keys published in
The diagnostic characters for Apolygus lucorum, A. nigronasutus, A. nigrovirens, A. malaisei and A. spinolae are inconsistent in some works (see Notes for A. spinolae in the Results section). Therefore, to test the species boundaries using the phylogeny we split the color morphs into species based on the original descriptions and the type specimens or their digital images we were able to examine. We applied the following criteria:
Apolygus lucorum: dorsum and head anteriorly green, without dark markings, cuneus entirely green (Meyer-Dür, 1943, paralectotype: Fig.
Apolygus nigronasutus: mostly pale green, at least half of clypeus dark brown to black, corium with distinct dark marking apically, extending to base of cuneus; apex of cuneus dark brown to black (
Apolygus spinolae: dorsum and head green, without dark markings, cuneus darkened apically (
Apolygus malaisei: body mostly dark brown to black, clypeus dark brown to black, pronotum dark brown to black, its posterior margin yellow medially, scutellum mostly dark brown to black with bases and apex yellow; clavus and corium mostly dark brown to black, cuneus green, without markings or with small dark brown to black marking apically (
Apolygus nigrovirens: less than third part of clypeus apically darkened, rarely entirely darkened or entirely pale, pronotum often with two or four brown markings, rarely entirely pale, sometimes posterior part mostly dark brown; scutellum often pale, sometimes mostly dark brown with pale apex; clavus mostly dark brown or at least with brown stripe; corium with dark brown marking near cuneus, sometimes other markings also present, its outer margin pale; cuneus with distinct dark marking apically (
In some cases, we could not assign a specimen to particular species. See Notes for Apolygus spinolae in the Results section for the detailed discussion of the morphological characters.
In total ca. 3000 specimens of Apolygus were examined. The collection event data for all of them were entered into the Arthropod Easy Capture Database (https://research.amnh.org/pbi/locality/index.php) and are available through the Heteroptera Species Pages (https://research.amnh.org/pbi/heteropteraspeciespage/speciesdetails.php). For the widely distributed and abundant species (A. lucorum, A. spinolae, A. malaisei, A. nigronasutus, A. nigrovirens, A. limbatus) at least 10 males and 10 females from different series for each species were dissected for examination of genitalia. For species which can be reliably identified using male genitalia, at least one male from each series was examined. The full list of all specimens examined is provided in File S1.
For molecular studies, 87 specimens from the following species were used: A. adustus, A. fraxinicola, A. furvus, A. hilaris, A. limbatus, A. lucorum, A. malaisei, A. nigronasutus, A. nigrovirens, A. spinolae, A. subpulchellus. Some specimens from A. lucorum, A. nigronasutus, A. nigrovirens, A. malaisei, A. spinolae complex could not be positively identified using coloration and morphology. Three specimens outside this complex could not be reliably placed to any known species, but they were also included in the analysis. Specimens were collected from 2006 to 2023 in 25 Russian administrative divisions and four other countries (Armenia, Bulgaria, Czech Republic, and Norway). Additionally, two specimens of Neolygus viridis and Taylorilygus apicalis were also processed for this study and used as outgroups. See Table SS1 for the full list of vouchers and sequences used for the analyses.
To examine the male and female genitalia structures, abdomens were removed and boiled in 10% KOH for up to five minutes and washed in water. After this procedure, the abdomens were dissected in stored glycerol. The drawings were completed using a Leica DM2500 microscope with the drawing device attached. The terminology of genitalia follows Konstantinov (
The digital images were taken in stacks using the Canon EOS 5D Mark IV camera. Partially focused images were combined using the Helicon Focus software. The scanning electron microscopy (SEM) images were taken from uncoated specimens using the Hitachi TM1000 tabletop microscope.
Measurements were completed using a LOMO microscope with a graticule and an 10× eyepiece, and they are provided in Table
| Length | Width | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Species | Body | Cun-Clyp | Pronotum | AntSeg1 | AntSeg2 | Head | Pronotum | InterOcDi | |
| A. adustus ♂ (N = 7) | Mean | 5,25 | 3,50 | 0,90 | 0,52 | 1,47 | 0,92 | 1,61 | 0,34 |
| SD | 0,23 | 0,15 | 0,06 | 0,04 | 0,09 | 0,07 | 0,10 | 0,02 | |
| Range | 0,50 | 0,42 | 0,18 | 0,10 | 0,27 | 0,18 | 0,31 | 0,05 | |
| Min | 5,08 | 3,33 | 0,78 | 0,46 | 1,33 | 0,82 | 1,42 | 0,31 | |
| Max | 5,58 | 3,75 | 0,96 | 0,56 | 1,60 | 1,00 | 1,73 | 0,36 | |
| ♀ (N = 7) | Mean | 5,57 | 3,72 | 1,73 | 0,56 | 1,63 | 0,97 | 1,73 | 0,36 |
| SD | 0,15 | 0,13 | 0,08 | 0,03 | 0,06 | 0,06 | 0,08 | 0,02 | |
| Range | 0,33 | 0,17 | 0,19 | 0,10 | 0,15 | 0,08 | 0,19 | 0,06 | |
| Min | 5,42 | 3,58 | 1,67 | 0,50 | 1,58 | 0,90 | 1,67 | 0,33 | |
| Max | 5,75 | 3,92 | 1,85 | 0,60 | 1,73 | 1,04 | 1,85 | 0,40 | |
| A. furvus ♂ (N = 7) | Mean | 5,71 | 3,99 | 0,84 | 0,48 | 1,35 | 0,83 | 1,54 | 0,33 |
| SD | 0,51 | 0,31 | 0,03 | 0,02 | 0,06 | 0,02 | 0,05 | 0,01 | |
| Range | 1,53 | 0,97 | 0,08 | 0,04 | 0,17 | 0,07 | 0,12 | 0,03 | |
| Min | 4,67 | 3,33 | 0,81 | 0,46 | 1,29 | 0,79 | 1,48 | 0,31 | |
| Max | 6,20 | 4,30 | 0,90 | 0,50 | 1,46 | 0,86 | 1,60 | 0,34 | |
| ♀ (N = 9) | Mean | 5,08 | 3,39 | 0,93 | 0,47 | 1,46 | 0,93 | 1,70 | 0,35 |
| SD | 0,24 | 0,18 | 0,05 | 0,01 | 0,07 | 0,04 | 0,07 | 0,02 | |
| Range | 0,67 | 0,58 | 0,17 | 0,04 | 0,19 | 0,13 | 0,23 | 0,06 | |
| Min | 4,83 | 3,17 | 0,88 | 0,46 | 1,35 | 0,88 | 1,63 | 0,31 | |
| Max | 5,50 | 3,75 | 1,04 | 0,50 | 1,54 | 1,00 | 1,85 | 0,38 | |
| A. sp. nr. furvus ♂ (N = 1) | Mean | 5,58 | 3,75 | 0,96 | N/A | N/A | 1,04 | 1,75 | 0,35 |
| A. fraxinicola ♂ (N = 7) | Mean | 5,37 | 3,70 | 0,91 | 0,55 | 1,54 | 0,94 | 1,63 | 0,36 |
| SD | 0,13 | 0,14 | 0,05 | 0,02 | 0,06 | 0,05 | 0,10 | 0,02 | |
| Range | 0,33 | 0,29 | 0,13 | 0,04 | 0,15 | 0,15 | 0,27 | 0,05 | |
| Min | 5,17 | 3,50 | 0,88 | 0,52 | 1,48 | 0,90 | 1,56 | 0,34 | |
| Max | 5,50 | 3,92 | 1,00 | 0,56 | 1,65 | 1,04 | 1,85 | 0,40 | |
| ♀ (N = 7) | Mean | 5,28 | 3,53 | 0,88 | 0,56 | 1,56 | 0,91 | 1,62 | 0,37 |
| SD | 0,27 | 0,18 | 0,02 | 0,04 | 0,09 | 0,03 | 0,09 | 0,02 | |
| Range | 0,67 | 0,50 | 0,06 | 0,08 | 0,25 | 0,09 | 0,26 | 0,07 | |
| Min | 4,92 | 3,25 | 0,85 | 0,52 | 1,40 | 0,88 | 1,49 | 0,33 | |
| Max | 5,58 | 3,75 | 0,92 | 0,60 | 1,65 | 0,97 | 1,75 | 0,41 | |
| A. kerzhneri ♂ (N = 3) | M1 | 5,08 | 3,42 | 0,81 | 0,46 | 1,31 | 0,79 | 1,47 | 0,31 |
| M2 | 4,67 | 3,25 | 0,94 | N/A | N/A | 0,85 | 1,60 | 0,35 | |
| M3 | 5,42 | 3,58 | 0,96 | N/A | N/A | 0,94 | 1,73 | 0,38 | |
| S. gotorum ♂ (N = 1) | M1 | N/A | 4,50 | 5,10 | N/A | N/A | 4,70 | 8,70 | 1,80 |
| A. hilaris ♂ (N = 5) | Mean | 5,17 | 4,22 | 1,38 | 0,46 | 1,38 | 0,91 | 1,69 | 0,34 |
| SD | 0,63 | 0,50 | 0,11 | 0,04 | 0,11 | 0,03 | 0,22 | 0,02 | |
| Range | 1,67 | 1,30 | 0,27 | 0,08 | 0,27 | 0,08 | 0,56 | 0,06 | |
| Min | 4,42 | 3,60 | 1,19 | 0,40 | 1,19 | 0,88 | 1,50 | 0,31 | |
| Max | 6,08 | 4,90 | 1,46 | 0,48 | 1,46 | 0,96 | 2,06 | 0,38 | |
| ♀ (N = 1) | F1 | 5,83 | 3,92 | 1,02 | 0,50 | 1,35 | 0,94 | 1,79 | 0,35 |
| S. infamis ♂ (N = 2) | M1 | 4,50 | 3,17 | 0,79 | 0,48 | 1,40 | 0,90 | 1,43 | 0,33 |
| M2 | 4,83 | 3,33 | 0,85 | 0,52 | 1,65 | 0,94 | 1,58 | 0,35 | |
| A. limbatus European form ♂ (N = 7) | Mean | 5,08 | 3,38 | 0,78 | 0,48 | 1,45 | 0,93 | 1,48 | 0,39 |
| SD | 0,19 | 0,17 | 0,07 | 0,04 | 0,11 | 0,05 | 0,09 | 0,03 | |
| Range | 0,58 | 0,50 | 0,19 | 0,13 | 0,27 | 0,13 | 0,27 | 0,06 | |
| Min | 4,83 | 3,08 | 0,73 | 0,44 | 1,38 | 0,89 | 1,44 | 0,38 | |
| Max | 5,42 | 3,58 | 0,88 | 0,56 | 1,63 | 1,00 | 1,60 | 0,42 | |
| ♀ (N = 7) | Mean | 5,06 | 3,38 | 0,85 | 0,50 | 1,51 | 0,99 | 1,56 | 0,42 |
| SD | 0,18 | 0,21 | 0,06 | 0,03 | 0,07 | 0,04 | 0,09 | 0,02 | |
| Range | 0,50 | 0,63 | 0,17 | 0,10 | 0,21 | 0,14 | 0,25 | 0,06 | |
| Min | 4,67 | 2,92 | 0,77 | 0,46 | 1,40 | 0,93 | 1,42 | 0,40 | |
| Max | 5,17 | 3,54 | 0,94 | 0,56 | 1,60 | 1,06 | 1,67 | 0,46 | |
| A. limbatus Asian form ♂ (N = 8) | Mean | 5,26 | 3,44 | 0,87 | 0,49 | 1,49 | 0,88 | 1,42 | 0,38 |
| SD | 0,17 | 0,11 | 0,07 | 0,03 | 0,11 | 0,88 | 1,40 | 0,38 | |
| Range | 0,42 | 0,33 | 0,17 | 0,06 | 0,31 | 1,02 | 1,58 | 0,40 | |
| Min | 5,08 | 3,25 | 0,77 | 0,46 | 1,33 | 0,96 | 1,58 | 0,42 | |
| Max | 5,50 | 3,58 | 0,94 | 0,52 | 1,65 | 1,00 | 1,67 | 0,44 | |
| ♀ (N = 7) | Mean | 5,26 | 3,51 | 0,87 | 0,51 | 1,56 | 0,98 | 1,62 | 0,43 |
| SD | 0,18 | 0,10 | 0,06 | 0,03 | 0,10 | 0,05 | 0,06 | 0,02 | |
| Range | 0,58 | 0,33 | 0,17 | 0,08 | 0,25 | 0,13 | 0,19 | 0,06 | |
| Min | 4,92 | 3,33 | 0,79 | 0,48 | 1,46 | 0,92 | 1,52 | 0,40 | |
| Max | 5,50 | 3,67 | 0,96 | 0,56 | 1,71 | 1,04 | 1,71 | 0,46 | |
| A. maackiae ♂ (N = 7) | Mean | 4,40 | 2,93 | 0,69 | 0,45 | 1,26 | 0,72 | 1,21 | 0,27 |
| SD | 0,16 | 0,10 | 0,03 | 0,01 | 0,03 | 0,02 | 0,02 | 0,00 | |
| Range | 0,42 | 0,33 | 0,08 | 0,02 | 0,06 | 0,05 | 0,06 | 0,01 | |
| Min | 4,17 | 2,75 | 0,65 | 0,44 | 1,23 | 0,70 | 1,19 | 0,26 | |
| Max | 4,58 | 3,08 | 0,73 | 0,46 | 1,29 | 0,75 | 1,25 | 0,27 | |
| A. shikotan ♂ (N = 4) | M1 | 4,67 | 3,08 | 0,79 | 0,44 | 1,35 | 0,88 | 1,48 | 0,35 |
| M2 | 4,42 | 3,08 | 0,73 | 0,46 | 1,29 | 0,83 | 1,38 | 0,31 | |
| M3 | 4,75 | 3,08 | 0,79 | N/A | N/A | 0,85 | 1,90 | 0,31 | |
| M4 | 4,42 | 3,00 | 0,78 | N/A | N/A | 0,85 | 1,94 | 0,33 | |
| ♀ (N = 1) | F1 | N/A | N/A | 0,92 | 0,42 | N/A | 0,98 | 1,65 | 0,35 |
| A. spinolae ♂ (N = 35) | Mean | 5,47 | 3,59 | 0,81 | 0,51 | 1,44 | 0,87 | 1,51 | 0,34 |
| SD | 0,31 | 0,18 | 0,05 | 0,04 | 0,12 | 0,04 | 0,07 | 0,02 | |
| Range | 0,83 | 0,33 | 0,13 | 0,08 | 0,33 | 0,09 | 0,21 | 0,04 | |
| Min | 4,83 | 3,33 | 0,71 | 0,44 | 1,21 | 0,78 | 1,38 | 0,31 | |
| Max | 6,25 | 4,17 | 0,90 | 0,60 | 1,69 | 0,96 | 1,69 | 0,38 | |
| ♀ (N = 35) | Mean | 5,41 | 3,57 | 0,82 | 0,50 | 1,37 | 0,87 | 1,54 | 0,36 |
| SD | 0,28 | 0,18 | 0,05 | 0,03 | 0,25 | 0,04 | 0,08 | 0,02 | |
| Range | 1,67 | 1,17 | 0,23 | 0,15 | 1,27 | 0,17 | 0,38 | 0,10 | |
| Min | 4,58 | 3,00 | 0,67 | 0,44 | 0,46 | 0,77 | 1,31 | 0,29 | |
| Max | 6,25 | 4,17 | 0,90 | 0,58 | 1,73 | 0,94 | 1,69 | 0,40 | |
| A. subhilaris ♂ (N = 9) | Mean | 4,90 | 3,32 | 0,93 | 0,87 | 1,55 | 0,32 | 0,46 | 1,33 |
| SD | 0,22 | 0,19 | 0,10 | 0,07 | 0,12 | 0,03 | 0,02 | 0,05 | |
| Range | 0,50 | 0,50 | 0,31 | 0,21 | 0,38 | 0,06 | 0,04 | 0,13 | |
| Min | 4,67 | 3,08 | 0,77 | 0,77 | 1,38 | 0,29 | 0,44 | 1,25 | |
| Max | 5,17 | 3,58 | 1,08 | 0,98 | 1,75 | 0,35 | 0,48 | 1,38 | |
| ♀ (N = 2) | F1 | 5,08 | 3,42 | 0,94 | 0,35 | 1,25 | 0,81 | 1,56 | 0,31 |
| F2 | 0,00 | 3,33 | 1,06 | 0,00 | 0,00 | 0,94 | 1,79 | 0,38 | |
| A. subpulchellus ♂ (N = 7) | Mean | 4,62 | 3,06 | 0,73 | 0,43 | 1,28 | 0,81 | 1,33 | 0,27 |
| SD | 0,29 | 0,20 | 0,05 | 0,01 | 0,07 | 0,02 | 0,09 | 0,01 | |
| Range | 0,58 | 0,50 | 0,17 | 0,04 | 0,21 | 0,06 | 0,23 | 0,01 | |
| Min | 4,33 | 2,83 | 0,65 | 0,42 | 1,15 | 0,77 | 1,21 | 0,27 | |
| Max | 5,08 | 3,33 | 0,81 | 0,46 | 1,35 | 0,84 | 1,44 | 0,28 | |
| ♀ (N = 7) | Mean | 4,73 | 3,18 | 0,76 | 0,44 | 1,23 | 0,82 | 1,37 | 0,31 |
| SD | 0,28 | 0,21 | 0,07 | 0,03 | 0,10 | 0,04 | 0,08 | 0,01 | |
| Range | 0,67 | 0,50 | 0,21 | 0,07 | 0,29 | 0,10 | 0,23 | 0,04 | |
| Min | 4,33 | 2,92 | 0,65 | 0,39 | 1,02 | 0,76 | 1,23 | 0,29 | |
| Max | 5,00 | 3,42 | 0,85 | 0,46 | 1,31 | 0,86 | 1,46 | 0,33 | |
| A. watajii ♂ (N = 7) | Mean | 5,27 | 3,46 | 0,82 | 0,48 | 1,43 | 0,87 | 1,49 | 0,32 |
| SD | 0,12 | 0,13 | 0,04 | 0,04 | 0,06 | 0,05 | 0,09 | 0,02 | |
| Range | 0,42 | 0,42 | 0,10 | 0,10 | 0,21 | 0,13 | 0,22 | 0,05 | |
| Min | 5,27 | 3,46 | 0,82 | 0,48 | 1,43 | 0,87 | 1,49 | 0,32 | |
| Max | 5,50 | 3,67 | 0,88 | 0,52 | 1,52 | 0,94 | 1,58 | 0,35 | |
| ♀ (N = 7) | Mean | 4,35 | 2,92 | 0,90 | 0,41 | 1,27 | 0,79 | 1,34 | 0,32 |
| SD | 1,95 | 1,30 | 0,06 | 0,19 | 0,58 | 0,35 | 0,59 | 0,14 | |
| Range | 5,58 | 3,58 | 0,13 | 0,56 | 1,63 | 1,00 | 1,67 | 0,40 | |
| Min | 4,35 | 2,92 | 0,90 | 0,41 | 1,27 | 0,79 | 1,34 | 0,32 | |
| Max | 5,58 | 3,58 | 0,94 | 0,56 | 1,63 | 1,00 | 1,67 | 0,40 | |
DNA was extracted from abdomens of ethanol-stored and dry specimens using the Evrogen Extract DNA Blood and Cells kit. Two modifications to the standard protocol were applied to obtain higher DNA concentrations. First, the abdomens were kept overnight in the lysis solution with proteinase K in the water bath. Second, 50 or 25 μl of the elution buffer was added at the final stage. After lysis, the abdomens were kept in glycerol for further examination. Previously three mitochondrial and two nuclear markers were used for the species delimitation within Miridae: COI, 12S rRNA, 16S rRNA, ITS1, Ca-ATPase (
Alignments for each marker were completed using the Geneious algorithm in Geneious v. 11 software. The Apolygus datasets included the following number of original sequences for each marker: 61 for COI, 83 for 16S rRNA, 63 for ITS1, and 64 for 28S rRNA. Additionally, the original sequences of Neolygus viridis and Taylorilygus apicalis were added to each alignment. Sequences were uploaded to Genbank. Sequences from Genbank were also added: 175 for COI, 29 for 16S rRNA and 21 for 28S rRNA, some of them were published in previous studies (
P-values were calculated in MEGA X (
Phylogenetic analyses were run for separate markers and different combinations of markers: (1) COI + 16S rRNA, (2) ITS1 + 28S rRNA, (3) 16S rRNA + ITS1 + 28S rRNA (4) 16S rRNA + ITS1, (5) COI + 16S rRNA + 28S rRNA, (6) COI + 16S rRNA + ITS1 + 28S3 rRNA. In each analysis only specimens having all sequences used in the particular dataset were included, because missing data can affect support values and topology (e.g.,
To estimate divergence dates, the STARBEAST2 package implemented in BEAST2.7 was used. Analyses were performed on three datasets 16S rRNA + ITS1, 16S rRNA + ITS1 + 28S rRNA and ITS1 + 28S rRNA, because the trees based on them showed the best resolution and their topologies corresponded most closely to morphology (see Results section). Parameters were set according to the manual of H.A. Ogilvie (https://taming-the-beast.org/tutorials/calibrated-species-trees/calibrated-species-trees.pdf). The evolutionary rates estimated for insects in the previous works were used for tree calibration: for COI—0.0177 per Myr, for 16S rRNA—0.0054 per Myr, and for ITS1—0.0085 per Myr, 28S3 rRNA—0.0006 per Myr (
Bootstrap support values from the RAXML analyses are abbreviated as BS, posterior probabilities (PP) for MRBAYES, STARBEAST2 and STARBEAST3 analyses are abbreviated PPMB, PPSB2 and PPSB3, respectively.
Species delimitation analyses were performed on the ITS1, ITS1 + 28S rRNA, 16S rRNA + 28S rRNA, and 16S rRNA + ITS1 + 28S rRNA datasets, because they were the most resolved and corresponded the morphological data the best (see Results section). Generalized Mixed Yule Coalescent approach (bGMYC) (
Automatic Barcode Gap Discovery (ABGD) analysis (
The package speedemon in BEAST2.7.7 performs species delimitation under the multispecies coalescence (
The supports for the main clades for all analyses are provided in the Table S3. None of the phylogenetic trees recover Apolygus lucorum and Apolygus spinolae as separate clades. The trees based on 28S rRNA only are unresolved, therefore, they are not described and discussed further (Figs S1, S19). Results show that COI is the least reliable among other markers used. First, the COI sequences of M46 (A. lucorum from Yakutia Republic, Russia) and M64 (A. lucorum from Leningrad Province, Russia) have gaps and many substitutions and can represent pseudogenes (see Discussion). Therefore, those sequences were removed from the combined analyses. Second, the specimens of Apolygus fraxinicola (M189, M190) collected during a single collection event, as well as sequences of Apolygus adustus and Apolygus subpulchellus never form clades based on the dataset comprising mitochondrial markers only (Figs
The phylogeny based on the 16S rRNA + ITS1 + 28S3 rRNA dataset obtained from the STARBEAST3 analysis. The bootstrap supports are provided above the branches. The upper left support is PPSB3, the upper right supports is PPSB2, the lower left supports is PPMB, and the lower right supports is BS. The results of the species delimitation analysis are provided on the right-hand side.
The phylogeny based on the ITS1 + 28S3 rRNA dataset obtained from the STARBEAT3 analysis. The bootstrap supports are provided above the branches. The upper left support is PPSB3, the upper right supports is PPSB2, the lower left supports is PPMB, and the lower right supports is BS. The results of the species delimitation analysis are provided on the right-hand side.
The greatest diversity from the East Asian species was included from Genbank, represented by COI, 16S rRNA and 28S rRNA markers. However, COI and 16S rRNA are compromised by possible hybridization (see Discussion), and 16S rRNA and 28S rRNA show low genetic variation. Therefore, interspecies relationships inferred based on the combination of these markers cannot be considered as reliable, and they are not described further (Figs
Overall, the phylogenies based on 16S rRNA + ITS1 + 28S rRNA show the most resolution and its results mostly correspond to the morphological data. They show that the specimens of A. lucorum, A. malaisei, A. nigronasutus, A. nigrovirens, and A. spinolae form a clade with high supports (BS = 73, PP = 0.92–1) (Figs
In the analyses based on the 16S rRNA + ITS1 + 28S rRNA and ITS1 + 28S rRNA, Apolygus adustus, A. fraxinicola, A. limbatus, A. subpulchellus, and A. sp. nr. furvus M199 were included (Figs
The species delimitation results are summarized in Table S4. The PTP and bPTP analyses show more than five species within the A. lucorum, A. malaisei, A. nigronasutus, A. nigrovirens, and A. spinolae complex for all datasets, which is, apparently, incorrect, considering the low genetic variability (see below) and the lack of discrete morphological differences within this group. The results based on ITS1 only do not correspond to the morphospecies. In particular, ABGD does not split the sequences into the groups, and GMYC show more than five species within the A. lucorum, A. malaisei, A. nigronasutus, A. nigrovirens, and A. spinolae group. However, GMYC analyses for the combined datasets assigned all specimens according to the morphospecies (Figs
The P-values are provided in the Table S5. The genetic diversity is similar for COI and ITS1, and it is significantly lower for 16S rRNA. The mean genetic diversity for the entire Apolygus dataset for COI is 0.026, for ITS1 – 0.02, for 16S rRNA – 0.01, and for 28S rRNA – 0.003. The mean diversity within A. lucorum, A. malaisei, A. nigronasutus, A. nigrovirens, A. spinolae group for COI is 0.013, for ITS1 – 0.011, for 16S rRNA – 0.0058, and for 28S rRNA – 0.0016. Distances between this group and most other species are 4–5% for COI, 2–6% for ITS1, 1–3% for 16S rRNA, and 0.2–1.5% for 28S rRNA The exception is A. watajii, the mean distances between this species and A. lucorum, A. malaisei, A. nigronasutus, A. nigrovirens, and A. spinolae complex are 1.5% for COI, 0.3% for 16S rRNA and 0.08% for 28S rRNA
Haplotype networks are provided in Fig.
The haplotype networks. With all Apolygus species available, including downloaded from Genbank. A Based on COI. B Based on 16S rRNA. C Based on ITS1. With the sequences of Apolygus lucorum, A. malaisei, A. nigronasutus, A. nigrovirens, and A. spinolae obtained for the current study. D Based on 16S rRNA. E Based on COI. F Based on ITS1.
Haplotype networks for the A. lucorum, A. malaisei, A. nigronasutus, A. nigrovirens, and A. spinolae group only show that specimens with different color morphs can have identical haplotypes. The haplotype networks for COI and 16S rRNA do not show any structure corresponding to the color morphs. However, the network based on ITS1 shows two haplogroups, one of them includes all specimens of A. spinolae and A. nigrovirens, as well as a single specimen of A. lucorum, the second haplogroup includes most specimens of A. lucorum, A. malaisei and A. nigronasutus.
The three datasets showed different results. The phylogeny based on nuclear markers only showed the oldest node ages and the phylogeny based on the 16S rRNA + ITS1 dataset showed the most recent node ages. The diversification of Apolygus species could have started between 6–16 Mya (Miocene), A. spinolae may have split from the other species between 1.9–3.7 Mya (Pliocene – Pleistocene), and the two clades within A. spinolae diverged between 1.1–2.1 Mya (Pleistocene: Calabrian and Gelasian ages).
We mostly agree with the diagnosis of Apolygus provided by
SEM images. A A. subpulchellus, head and pronotum, lateral view, ZISP_ENT 00003767. B A. limbatus, Europe, Head and pronotum, lateral view, ZISP_ENT 00016011. C A. limbatus, Europe, cuneus and membrane, ZISP_ENT 00015959. D A. limbatus Europe, head and pronotum, dorsal view, ZISP_ENT 00015959. E Pretarsus, dorsal view, A. spinolae, ZISP_ENT 00015686. F Pleura, A. limbatus, Europe, ZISP_ENT 00016011. G Pleura, A. maackiae, ZISP_ENT 00016248. H Pretarsus, ventral view, A. spinolae, ZISP_ENT 00015187. I Scutellum, clavus, corium, A. adustus, ZISP_ENT 00015920. J Labium, A. subpulchellus, ZISP_ENT 00015177. K Hind tarsus, A. maackiae, ZISP_ENT 00016246.
Female genitalia. A. adustus, ZISP_ENT 00016215. A Dorsal labiate plate. B Posterior wall. A. fraxinicola ZISP_ENT 00016592. C Posterior wall. D Dorsal labiate plate. A. furvus, holotype series, ZISP_ENT 00016298. E Dorsal labiate plate. F Posterior wall. A. furvus, paratype series, ZISP_ENT 00016055. G Dorsal labiate plate. H Posterior wall.
Female genitalia. A. hilaris ZISP_ENT 00014894. A Dorsal labiate plate. B Posterior wall. A. shikotan sp. nov. ZISP_ENT 00014895. C Posterior wall. D Dorsal labiate plate. A. limbatus Europe, ZISP_ENT 00016026. E Dorsal labiate plate. F Posterior wall. A. limbatus Asia. G Posterior wall, ZISP_ENT 00015935. H Dorsal labiate plate, ZISP_ENT 00014890. A. subpulchellus, ZISP_ENT 00003766. I Dorsal labiate plate. G Posterior wall.
Female genitalia. A. spinolae. A Dorsal labiate plate, ZISP_ENT 00014490. B Posterior wall, ZISP_ENT 00015712. A. subhilaris ZISP_ENT 000116157. C Posterior wall. D Dorsal labiate plate. A. sp. nr. subhilaris, ZISP_ENT 00014784. E Dorsal labiate plate. F Posterior wall. A. watajii, ZISP_ENT 0006039. G Dorsal labiate plate. H Posterior wall. I Ventral wall.
Left parameres. A. adustus ZISP_ENT 00014862. A dorsal view. B posterior view. A. fraxinicola. ZISP_ENT 00014862. С dorsal view. D. posterior view. A. furvus, holotype ZISP_ENT 00016303. E dorsal view. F posterior view. A. furvus, paratype ZISP_ENT 00015924. G dorsal view. H posterior view. AK genital capsule. A. gotorum ZISP_ENT 00016164. I posterior view. A. hilaris ZISP_ENT 00014891. J dorsal view. K posterior view. A. hilaris, holotype of A. syringae ZISP_ENT 00014891. L dorsal view. M posterior view. A. infamis ZISP_ENT 00014891. N dorsal view. O posterior view. A. maackiae ZISP_ENT 00014893. P dorsal view. Q posterior view. A. limbatus Europe, ZISP_ENT 00016012. R dorsal view. S posterior view. A. limbatus Asia, ZISP_ENT 00014886. T dorsal view. U posterior view. V theca. A. shikotan sp. nov. ZISP_ENT 00016047 holotype. W dorsal view. X posterior view. A. spinolae ZISP_ENT 00005858. Y dorsal view. Z posterior view. A. subhilaris ZISP_ENT 00016582. AA dorsal view. AB posterior view. A. sp. nr. subhilaris ZISP_ENT 00014867. AC dorsal view. AD posterior view. A. subpulchellus ZISP_ENT 00003765. AE dorsal view. AF posterior view. A. watajii ZISP_ENT 00003760. AG dorsal view. AH posterior view. A. sp. nr. furvus ZISP_ENT 00014869. AI dorsal view. AJ posterior view.
Habitus, dorsal view. A. adustus. A Male, ZISP_ENT 00016237. B Female, ZISP_ENT 00015922. A. fraxinicola. C Female, ZISP_ENT 00016596. D Male, ZISP_ENT 00015938. A. furvus. E Male, holotype. ZISP_ENT 00016303. F Female, ZISP_ENT 00016297. A. gotorum. G Male, ZISP_ENT 00016232. A. hilaris. H Male, ZISP_ENT 00015182. I Female, paratype, ZISP_ENT 00015184. A. infamis. J Male, ZISP_ENT 00016250, holotype.
Habitus, dorsal view. A. limbatus. A Europe, Female, ZISP_ENT 00015986. B Asia, Male, ZISP_ENT 00015917. C Europe, Male, ZISP_ENT 00016005. D Asia, Female, ZISP_ENT 00015918. A. maackiae. E Male, ZISP_ENT 00016046. A. shikotan sp. nov. F Male, paratype, ZISP_ENT 00016048. A. subhilaris. G Male, ZISP_ENT 00016193. H Female, ZISP_ENT 00016158. A. sp. nr. subhilaris. I Male, ZISP_ENT 00016162. J Female, ZISP_ENT 00014874.
Habitus, dorsal view. A. spinolae. Specimens initially identified as A. nigronasutus. A Male, ZISP_ENT 00014451. B Female, ZISP_ENT 00014477. Specimens initially identified as A. nigrovirens. C Male, ZISP_ENT 00014590. D Male, ZISP_ENT 00014604. E Female, ZISP_ENT 00014618. F Female, ZISP_ENT 00014738. Specimens initially identified as A. spinolae. G Male, ZISP_ENT 00014775. H Female, ZISP_ENT 00014766. Specimens initially identified as A. malaisei. I Female, ZISP_ENT 00015747. J Male, ZISP_ENT 00015764. K Male, ZISP_ENT 00015656. Specimens initially identified as A. lucorum. L Male, ZISP_ENT 00006565. M Female, ZISP_ENT 00006918.
The digital images of paralectotypes preserved at the American Museum of Natural History, New York. Capsus lucorum Meyer-Dür, 1843 (AMNH_IZC 00396564), female. A Dorsal view. B Frontal view. C Labels. D Left lateral view. Capsus spinolae Meyer-Dür, 1841 (AMNH_IZC 00396565), female. E Dorsal view. F Frontal view. G Labels. H Left lateral view.
Head, frontal view. A. adustus. A Male, ZISP_ENT 00016237. A. fraxinicola. B Female, ZISP_ENT 00016596. A. furvus. C Male, ZISP_ENT 00016303, holotype. A. gotorum. D Male, ZISP_ENT 00016232. A. hilaris. E Female, paratype, ZISP_ENT 00015184. A. infamis. F Male, paratype, ZISP_ENT 00016250, holotype. A. limbatus. G Asia, Male, ZISP_ENT 00015917. H Europe, Male, ZISP_ENT 00015986. A. maackiae. I Male, ZISP_ENT 00016046. A. shikotan sp. nov. J Male, holotype, ZISP_ENT 00016047 K Male, paratype, ZISP_ENT 00016047. A. subhilaris. L Female, ZISP_ENT 00016158. A. sp. nr. subhilaris. M Female, ZISP_ENT 00014874. A. subpulchellus. N Male, ZISP_ENT 00016042, paralectotype. A. watajii. O Male, paratype, ZISP_ENT 00016241. P Female, ZISP_ENT 00016243. A. spinolae. Q Specimen initially identified as A. lucorum, Male, ZISP_ENT 00006565. R Specimen initially identified as A. spinolae, Female, ZISP_ENT 00014766. S Specimen initially identified as A. nigronasutus, Male, ZISP_ENT 00014551. T Specimen initially identified as A. nigrovirens, Male, ZISP_ENT 00014590. U Specimen initially identified as A. nigrovirens, Female, ZISP_ENT 00014618. V Specimen initially identified as A. malaisei, Female, ZISP_ENT 00015747. W Specimen initially identified as A. malaisei Male, ZISP_ENT 00015764.
Vesica. A. adustus, ZISP_ENT 00014889. A Right lateral view. B Left lateral view. A. sp. nr. furvus (M199), ZISP_ENT 00014869. C Right lateral view. D Left lateral view. A. fraxinicola, ZISP_ENT 00014887. E Right lateral view. F Left lateral view. A. furvus (holotype), ZISP_ENT 00016303. G Right lateral view. H Left lateral view. A. gotorum, ZISP_ENT 00016232. I Right lateral view. J Left lateral view. A. furvus (paratype), ZISP_ENT 00003762. K Right lateral view. L Left lateral view.
Vesica. A. spinolae. A Right lateral view, ZISP_ENT 00006623. B Left lateral view, ZISP_ENT 00005851. C Right lateral view, ZISP_ENT 00015780. D Anterior view, ZISP_ENT 00005851. E Lateral and sublateral sclerites, left lateral view, ZISP_ENT 00005851. A. subpulchellus, ZISP_ENT 00016047. F Right lateral view. G Left lateral view. A. sp. nr. subhilaris, (M197) ZISP_ENT 00014867. H Right lateral view. I Left lateral view. A. subhilaris, ZISP_ENT 00016193. J Right lateral view. K Left lateral view. A. watajii, ZISP_ENT 00016193. L Right lateral view, ZISP_ENT 00016247. M Left lateral view, ZISP_ENT 00003760.
Vesica. A. hilaris, ZISP_ENT 00014891. A Right lateral view. B Left lateral view, A. infamis, ZISP_ENT 00016252. C Right lateral view. D Left lateral view. A. limbatus, Europe, ZISP_ENT 00016012. E Right lateral view. F Left lateral view. A. maackiae, ZISP_ENT 00016247. G Right lateral view. H Left lateral view. A. limbatus, Asia, ZISP_ENT 00014886. I Right lateral view. J Left lateral view. A. subpulchellus, ZISP_ENT 00003765. K Right lateral view. L Left lateral view.
Right parameres. A. adustus ZISP_ENT 00014862. A dorsal view. B posterior view. A. fraxinicola ZISP_ENT 00014862. C dorsal view. D posterior view. A. furvus, holotype, ZISP_ENT 00016303. E dorsal view. F posterior view. A. furvus, paratype ZISP_ENT 00015924. G dorsal view. H posterior view. A. gotorum ZISP_ENT 00016164. I dorsal view, J posterior view. A. hilaris ZISP_ENT 00014891. K dorsal view. L posterior view. A. hilaris, holotype of A. syringae ZISP_ENT 00015180. M dorsal view. N posterior view. A. infamis ZISP_ENT 00016250. O dorsal view. P posterior view. A. maackiae, ZISP_ENT 00014893. Q dorsal view. R posterior view. A. limbatus Europe ZISP_ENT 00016012. S dorsal view. T posterior view. A. limbatus Asia ZISP_ENT 00014886. U dorsal view. V posterior view. A. shikotan sp. nov. ZISP_ENT 00016047, holotype. W dorsal view. X posterior view. A. spinolae ZISP_ENT 00005858. Y dorsal view. Z posterior view. A. subhilaris, ZISP_ENT 00016582. AA dorsal view. AB posterior view. A. sp. nr. A. subhilaris ZISP_ENT 00014867. AC dorsal view. AD posterior view. A. subpulchellus ZISP_ENT 00003765. AE dorsal view. AF posterior view. A. watajii ZISP_ENT 00003760. AG dorsal view. AH posterior view. A. sp. nr. furvus ZISP_ENT 00014869. AI dorsal view. AJ posterior view.
As a result of this study, A. lucorum, A. malaisei, A. nigronasutus, and A. nigrovirens were synonymized with A. spinolae. The synonymy of A. syringae with A. hilaris was confirmed, Apolygus gotorum and Apolygus subhilaris were recorded from Russia for the first time. Apolygus shikotan sp. nov. is described as new to science. Therefore, 13 species of Apolygus are currently known from Russia. Here we provide an identification key and diagnoses for all those species. In some cases, only males can be used for reliable species identification.
| 1 | Dorsum mostly green or yellow, small brown to black markings often present at posterior part of corium, usually not reaching embolium and apex of clavus (Figs |
2 |
| 1’ | Dorsum color ranging from yellow to entirely dark brown to black; if dorsum mostly yellow then corium with large brown to dark brown marking basally reaching clavus and outer margin of embolium (Figs |
3 |
| 2 | Wing shaped sclerite elongate, 3–4× as long as wide (Fig. |
A. spinolae |
| 2’ | Wing shaped sclerite widened, twice as long as wide (Fig. |
A. watajii |
| 3 | Corium dark brown to black (Figs |
4 |
| 3’ | Corium at least with pale brown to yellow marking or mostly pale brown to yellow (Figs |
6 |
| 4 | Hind femur yellow, yellow with reddish tinge or red with distinct brown or dark red bands on the apical half of hind femur; outer margin of wing shaped sclerite straight; sublateral sclerite acute, narrower than secondary gonopore (Fig. |
A. furvus |
| 4’ | Hind femur mostly bright red, brown or dark red bands on the apical half of hind femur pale or absent; outer margin of wing-shaped sclerite in vesica distinctly concave medially; sublateral sclerite rounded, wider than secondary gonopore (Figs |
5 |
| 5 | Apical process of right paramere shorter than paramere body (Fig. |
A. shikotan sp. nov. |
| 5’ | Apical process of right paramere subequal to paramere body (Fig. |
A. infamis |
| 6 | Cuneus mostly yellow or green, its apical part yellow or with faint and small brown marking (Fig. |
A. limbatus |
| 6’ | Apical part of cuneus distinctly dark brown to black (Figs |
7 |
| 7 | Dark marking at corium base not reaching outer margin of embolium (Fig. |
A. maackiae |
| 7’ | Dark marking at corium base often reaching outer margin of embolium (Figs |
8 |
| 8 | Clypeus mostly yellow, sometimes dark brown to black at very apex (Fig. |
9 |
| 8’ | At least half of clypeus dark brown to black (Fig. |
10 |
| 9 | Antennal segment I mostly yellow, vesica with needle-shaped sclerite very short, not reaching secondary gonopore, or indistinct (Fig. |
A. subhilaris |
| 9’ | Antennal segment I dark brown to black; vesica with needle-shaped sclerite surpassing secondary gonopore (Fig. |
A. gotorum |
| 10 | Antennal segment II either dark brown to black or with pale brown or yellow ring on basal half; wing-shaped sclerite small, subequal to 1/5 of ventral sclerite (Fig. |
A. hilaris |
| 10’ | Antennal segment II usually yellow to pale brown and darkened apically, sometimes mostly dark brown to black with basal 1/3–1/4 yellow to pale brown; wing-shaped sclerite subequal to at least 1/3 of ventral sclerite (Figs |
11 |
| 11 | Cuneus yellow with dark base and apex with red tinge or entirely brown to black (Fig. |
A. fraxinicola |
| 11’ | Cuneus yellow with dark base and apex, without red tinge; needle-shaped sclerite absent (Figs |
12 |
| 12 | Larger, total length ♂ 5.1–5.6 mm, ♀ 5.5–5.8 mm; scutellum yellow, brown to dark brown basally (Fig. |
A. adustus |
| 12’ | Smaller, total length ♂ 4.3–5.1 mm, ♀ 4.3–5.0 mm; scutellum either entirely yellow or with pale brown to brown subrectangular marking (Fig. |
A. subpulchellus |
Lygus adustus
Lygus adustus var. bicolor
Lygocoris adustus
Lygocoris (Apolygus) adustus
Apolygus adustus Kuik 1974: 11 (annotated list);
For the full list of references and synonyms see
Type material. Lectotype: RUSSIA • ♂; Primorsky Terr.: Lesozavodsk [Ussuri], 45.46666°N, 133.41666°E, no date provided, V. Jakovlev coll., (ZISP_ENT 00016235) – Paralectotypes: RUSSIA • 2♂♂; Primorsky Terr.— Other material. RUSSIA, Khabarovsk Terr., Primorsky Terr. • many ♂♂, ♀♀ (see File S1).
Length in male 5.1–5.6 mm, in female 5.4–5.8 mm. Head mostly yellow; clypeus mostly dark brown (Fig.
Apolygus adustus is known from the Russian Far East: Amur Province – not confirmed, see Notes (
Apolygus adustus lives on broadleaf trees and bushes (
Among the Japanese species, A. adustus is similar to A. amamicus Yasunaga, 2023 in the coloration and size (
Lygocoris (Apolygus) fraxinicola
Lygocoris fraxinicola
Apolygus fraxinicola
For the full list of references see
Type material: Holotype: RUSSIA • 1♂; Primorsky Terr.: Kedrovaya Pad’ Nature Reserve, 43.067°N, 131.617°E, 29 Jun 1982, I. M. Kerzhner, Fraxinus rhynchophylla Hance (Oleaceae), (ZISP_ENT 00016585) – Paratypes: RUSSIA • 9♂♂, 13♀♀; Primorsky Terr. — Other material. RUSSIA, Khabarovsk Terr., Primorsky Terr. • 4♂♂, ♀ (See File S1).
Length in male 5.2–5.5 mm, in female 4.9–5.6 mm. Head color varying from mostly yellow to pale brown with red tinge, rarely mostly brown to dark brown; clypeus often mostly dark brown to black or only dark brown to black apically (Fig.
Apolygus fraxinicola is known from the Russian Far East: Primorsky Territory (
Specimens were collected from Fraxinus rhynchophylla and Fraxinus mandshurika (
Lygocoris (Apolygus) furvus
Lygocoris furvus
Lygocoris (Apolygus) hilaris
Apolygus furvus
For the full list of references see
Type material. Holotype: RUSSIA • 1♂; Sakhalin Prov.: Tobuti, Siretoko Peninusla, Sakhalin Is., 46.5°N, 143.3°E, 04 Aug 1947, Dyakonov, (ZISP_ENT 00016303) – Paratypes: RUSSIA • 3♂, 3♀; Sakhalin Prov. — Other material. JAPAN, RUSSIA, Primorsky Terr. • many ♂♂, ♀♀ (See File S1).
Length in male 4.7–6.2 mm, in female 4.8–5.5 mm. Body brown to dark brown, head yellow to pale brown with dark brown to black markings, sometimes mostly dark brown to black; clypeus dark brown to black (Fig.
Apolygus furvus inhabits Russian Far East: Amur Province – not confirmed, see Notes (
Apolygus furvus was collected from Hydrangea paniculata (Hydrangeaceae) (
In
Among the species known from the Russian Far East, A. furvus is most similar to A. infamis and A. shikotan sp. nov. These two species differ from A. furvus in the concave outer margin of wing-shaped sclerite (Figs
Apolygus gotorum
Other material. RUSSIA, Primorsky Terr. • 2♂ (see File S1).
(based on the specimens from ZIN and the original description). Length in male 4.5–5.4 mm, in female 5.3–5.8 mm. Head pale brown, apex of clypeus dark brown to black (Fig.
Japan (
The specimens were collected from the inflorescences of broadleaf trees (
Among the specimens previously identified as Apolygus furvus and Apolygus hilaris, we found two males from Suchan (Primorsky Territory), which did not belong to those species. Both specimens are partially damaged but fit the description of Apolygus gotorum and their male genitalia are also very similar to those published by
Cyphodema hilare
Lygus adustus ssp. hilaris
Lygocoris hilaris
Lygocoris (Apolygus) hilaris
Lygocoris (Apolygus) syringae
Apolygus hilaris
For the full list of references see
Other material. RUSSIA • 1♂; holotype of Lygocoris (Apolygus) syringae Kerzhner, 1988; Primorsky Terr.: Kedrovaya Pad’ Nature Reserve, 43.067°N, 131.617°E, 01 Jul 1982, I. M. Kerzhner, Syringa amurensis Rupr. (Oleaceae), (ZISP_ENT 00015180) • 3♂♂, 2♀♀; paratypes of Lygocoris (Apolygus) syringae Kerzhner, 1988; Primorsky Terr. • JAPAN, RUSSIA, Primorsky Terr. • ♂, ♀ (see File S1).
Length in male 4.4–6.1 mm, in female 5.8 mm. Head yellow with dark brown to black clypeus (Fig.
Apolygus hilaris is known from the Russian Far East: Primorskiy Territory (
Apolygus hilaris was recorded from Lonicera sp. (Caprifoliaceae) (ZIN), Syringae amurensis (Oleaceae) (
Apolygus syringae was described by
Apolygus hilaris is similar to a number of other species externally. Among the specimens found in the Russian Far East, A. hilaris is most similar with A. subhilaris, but the latter differs in the clypeus mostly pale and dark brown to black only apically (Fig.
Lygocoris (Apolygus) infamis
Lygocoris infamis
Apolygus infamis
For the full list of references see
Type material. Holotype: RUSSIA • 1♂; Primorsky Terr.: Suchan [Partizansk], 43.139°N, 133.141°E, 16 Sep 1934, Palshkov, (ZISP_ENT 00016250) – Paratype: RUSSIA • 1♂; Khabarovsk Terr. (See File S1).
Length in male 4.5–4.8 mm. Head yellow to pale brown with brown markings and dark brown to black clypeus (Fig.
Primorskiy Territory (
Apolygus infamis was described from the paratypes of A. furvus by
Among the species known from the Russian Far East, Apolygus infamis is similar to A. furvus and A. shikotan sp. nov., but those two species differ in the wing-shaped sclerite, which is ca. 0.75× as long as ventral sclerite (Figs
Lygaeus limbatus
Lygocoris (Apolygus) limbatus
Lygocoris limbatus
Lygus (Apolygus) limbatus
Apolygus limbatus
For the full list of references see
Other material. Belarus, Finland, Kazakhstan, Lithuania, Mongolia, Poland, Serbia, Russia, Altai Terr., Amur Prov., Arkhangelsk Prov., Bryansk Prov., Irkutsk Prov., Jewish Prov., Khabarovsk Terr., Khanty-Mansi Distr., Leningrad Prov., Magadan Prov., Primorsky Terr., Pskov Prov., Ryazan Prov., Samara Prov., Tula Prov., Yaroslavl Prov., Zabaikalsky Terr. • many ♂♂, ♀♀ (See File S1).
Length in male 4.8–5.4 mm (European form), 5.1–5.5 mm (Asian form), in female 4.7–5.2 mm (European form), 4.9–5.5 mm (Asian form). Head yellow, clypeus entirely or mostly pale brown to dark brown (Fig.
Apolygus limbatus can be considered as trans-Palearctic, but it does not live in the southern parts of Russia (
Apolygus limbatus lives on Salix spp. (
According to
We found that the specimens identified as A. limbatus have two types of sclerotization in vesica and this corresponds to the distribution: Europe (reaching Ural Mountains) and Asia (Fig.
Lygocoris (Apolygus) maackiae
Apolygus maackiae Kerzhner and Josifov, 1999: 65 (catalogue);
Type material. Holotype: RUSSIA • 1♂; Primorsky Terr.: Vladivostok, 43.11666°N, 131.9°E, 12 Aug 1964, Kulik, Maackia amurensis Rupr. (Fabaceae), (ZISP_ENT 00016249) – Paratype: RUSSIA • 1♂; Primorsky Terr. Other material. RUSSIA, Primorsky Terr. • 5♂♂ (See File S1).
Body length in male 4.0–4.6 mm; head yellow with at least apical half of clypeus dark brown to black (Fig.
Apolygus maackiae is recorded from Primorsky Territory (
Apolygus maackiae was initially recorded from Maackiae amurensis Rupr. (Fabaceae) (
This species is most similar to Apolygus limbatus in coloration. However, the latter differs in the legs often tinged with red, the cuneus not darkened apically (Fig.
Holotype: RUSSIA • 1♂; Sakhalin Prov.: Malokurilskoe, Shikotan Mt., Shikotan Island, 43.85°N, 146.81666°E, 20 Aug 1973, I. M. Kerzhner, 1♂ (ZISP_ENT 00016047) (ZIN). Paratypes: RUSSIA • 4♂♂, ♀; Sakhalin Prov. (See Data S1).
Length in male 4.4–4.8 mm. Head pale brown with brown stripes and dark brown to black clypeus or mostly dark brown to black (Fig.
MALE. Length in male 4.4–4.8 mm. — Coloration Head pale brown with brown stripes and dark brown to black clypeus or mostly dark brown to black (Fig.
Apolygus shikotan sp. nov. was recorded from a single location in the Kuril Islands, Russian Far East), however, at least some specimens of A. infamis from Japan can be attributed to this species too (see Notes for A. infamis).
The specimens of this species were collected from Phyllodendron sachalinense (Fr. Schmidt) Sarg. (Araceae) (
This species is named after Shikotan Island, where its specimens were collected.
We found that there are two species in the type series of Apolygus infamis, and only two specimens from the same locality belong to A. infamis. We describe the second species as new to science, A. shikotan sp. nov., because it does not fit a description of any other species known from this genus. There are only a few species with dark brown to black color of hemelytron without any stripes or markings on clavus and corium, i.e., Apolygus ater, A. atrobellus, A. furvellus, A. furvus, A. infamis, A. miyamotoanus, A. nigricans, A. rubriceps, and A. seonheulensis. In A. ater, A. furvellus, A. furvus, and A. infamis the apical process of right paramere is subequal to the paramere body (Fig.
Capsus spinolae
Capsus lucorum
Deraeocoris nigro-nasutus
Lygus (Neolygus) malaisei
Lygocoris (Apolygus) lucorum
Lygocoris (Apolygus) spinolae
Lygocoris (Apolygus) nigrovirens
Lygocoris (Apolygus) malaisei
Lygocoris (Apolygus) nigronasutus
Apolygus lucorum
Apolygus malaisei
Apolygus nigronasutus
Apolygus nigrovirens
Apolygus spinolae
For the full list of references see
Other material. RUSSIA • ♂; holotype of Lygocoris (Apolygus) nigrovirens Kerzhner, 1988; Sakhalin Prov.: Tret’yakovo, Kunashir Island, 43.98889°N, 145.64167°E, 03 Aug 1973, I. M. Kerzhner, 1♂ (ZISP_ENT 00015835) • 7♂♂, 4♀♀; paratypes of Lygocoris (Apolygus) nigrovirens Kerzhner, 1988; Primorsky Terr, Sakhalin Prov. • China, JAPAN, Mongolia, North Korea, South Korea, Ukraine, Russia • many ♂♂, ♀♀ (See File S1).
Length in male 4.8–6.3 mm, in female 4.7–6.3 mm. Head from uniformly yellow or green to mostly brown with yellow or green markings, clypeus from uniformly yellow or green to uniformly dark brown to black (Fig.
Apolygus spinolae is a trans-Palearctic species, known from Western Europe to Kuril Islands and Japan. It was recorded from the Caucasus but was not recorded from Iran (
Polyphagous. In particular, its specimens were collected from Thermopsis sp., Thermopsis lupinoides, Lespedeza sp. (Fabaceae), Artemisia spp., Tanacetum sp. (Asteraceae), Rosaceae, Urtica sp. (Urticaceae) (
In the consequent keys those two species were differentiated using the presence and absence of the marking on cuneus apically (
The color morphs associated with the species names in
Although some authors used the shape of wing shaped sclerite to separate A. lucorum and A. spinolae, they did not provide any particular ratio, using the descriptive terms “broad” and “slender” (Yasunaga 1992;
In the work of
Overall, we could not find any discrete characters in male genitalia in species group, comprising A. lucorum, A. malaisei, A. nigronasutus, A. nigrovirens, and A. spinolae. Both molecular and morphological characters indicate that the specimens previously identified as those five species represent a single polymorphic species. The examination of the previous literature shows that the criteria on how the researchers assign the specimens to those species are different in the different studies, and we should rely on the original descriptions and types to treat those species. The original description and the paralectotypes show only a single difference between A. lucorum and A. spinolae, which is the coloration of the apex of cuneus. The examination of the numerous specimens from the most part of the Palearctic shows that this character is variable and cannot be considered as discrete (Figs S12–S18). We could not examine the lectotypes and based on the original descriptions they should be mostly green with darkened membrane and the tarsi dark brown to black apically (Meyer-Dür 1941, 1943). The examination and dissection of those specimens will not provide any additional information, because they are females, and the differences in the female genitalia have never been reported for those two species, and we could not find them as well. The differences of the sclerite shapes are also not discrete and do not correspond to the color morphs.
Other species which have similar or the same male genitalia as A. spinolae and green or yellow coloration are Apolygus atrosignatus, A. halophilus, A. nepius, A. olivarius, A. rhamnicola, and A. watajii (
Lygocoris (Apolygus) subhilaris
Apolygus subhilaris
Non-type material. Japan, Russia: Amur Prov., Primorsky Terr. • 7♂♂, 3♀♀.
Length in male 4.7–5.2 mm, in female 5.1 mm. Head yellow with yellow clypeus, sometimes clypeus brown apically (Fig.
Previously this species was recorded from Japan (
In Korea this species was recorded from Lespedeza bicolor (Fabaceae) (
All specimens of this species included in this work were previously identified as Apolygus hilaris. The two species are very similar externally. Apolygus hilaris can be differentiated by the dark brown to brown clypeus (Fig.
Among the vouchers used for the molecular work, we found two specimens from Primorsky Territory which are very similar to A. subhilaris in coloration (M197, M124; Fig.
Lygocoris (Apolygus) subpulchellus
Apolygus subpulchellus
Type material. Holotype: RUSSIA • 1♂; Primorsky Terr.: Khasan Station, Golubiny Utes Tract, 42.417°N, 130.666°E, 24 Aug 1982, I. M. Kerzhner, Lespedeza bicolor Turcz. (Fabaceae), (ZISP_ENT 00015170) – Paratypes: JAPAN, RUSSIA, Primorsky terr • 55♂♂, 38♀♀, 5 unknown • Other material. Japan, South Korea, RUSSIA, Primorsky Terr • 5♂♂, ♀ (See File S1).
Length in male 4.3–5.1 mm, in female 4.3–5.0 mm. Head yellow, sometimes with pale brown to brown or red markings, clypeus dark brown (Fig.
Apolygus subpulchellus is recorded from Primorsky Territory (
Lespedeza bicolor (
Apolygus watajii
Type material. Paratypes: JAPAN, RUSSIA, Primorsky Terr. • 6♂♂, 4♀♀ • Other material. China, Russia, Khabarovsk Terr., Primorsky Terr. • many ♂♂, ♀♀ (See File S1).
Length in male 5.1–5.5 mm, in female 5.3–5.6 mm. Head mostly yellow green or green, clypeus usually uniformly dark brown to black, sometimes only its apical half dark brown to black (Fig.
In Russia Apolygus watajii was recorded from Primorskiy Territory (
In Korea this species was recorded from Persicaria spp. and Fagopyrum esculentum (Polygonaceae) (
Previous studies on other genera of Mirinae showed that the barcoding region of COI can be used for species delimitation (
In the present study, we used two mitochondrial (COI and 16S rRNA) and two nuclear markers (ITS1 and 28S rRNA). It was found that 28S rRNA sequences have a small number of substitutions, and its application for species delimitation or intraspecific studies is very limited. However, COI, 16S rRNA, and ITS1 have distinct intraspecific variation. We concluded that mitochondrial markers should not be used alone for species delimitation and inferring phylogenetic relationships within Apolygus. Apparently, there are at least two processes affecting the phylogenetic topology and haplotype composition based on COI in this case. First, sequences belonging to specimens of Apolygus lucorum from Yakutia Republic (M46) and Leningrad Province (M64) have gaps and many substitutions in comparisons with other specimens of A. lucorum, A. malaisei, A. nigronasutus, A. nigrovirens, and A. spinolae. The sequences of another mitochondrial marker, 16S rRNA, belonging to the same specimens (M46 and M64), do not significantly differ from other sequences belonging to the same species group. This means that the process affecting COI does not affect the entire mitochondrion, and this cannot be hybridization or Wolbachia effect. Therefore, pseudogenes (numts) explain the differences in sequences of M46 and M64 the best, and they we reported for the representatives of other insect groups (e.g.,
Hybridization is also possible within Apolygus. The phylogeny based on mitochondrial markers only shows that sequences of Apolygus fraxinicola (M189, M190) and Apolygus subpulchellus (M193, M217) do not form clades. However, in the trees based on ITS1, ITS1 + 28S rRNA, 16S rRNA + ITS1 and 16S rRNA + ITS + 28S rRNA those sequence pairs form clades with the highest supports. Additionally, Apolygus subpulchellus is monophyletic in the phylogeny based on four markers. This discrepancy between mitochondrial and nuclear markers can be explained by the current or historical hybridization, Wolbachia effect and incomplete lineage sorting. Incomplete lineage sorting is unlikely, because it would be expected that mitochondrial markers are sorted faster than nuclear markers because of the differences in the effective population size (e.g.,
Considering the synonyms and a species new to science proposed in this study, Apolygus currently includes 71 species, and, most probably, more new species are awaiting description. The most reliable set of characters for species identification is the vesica sclerotization. The shape of the right paramere also can be used for those purposes in some cases. Coloration is variable but often can be used for the identification purposes, especially in combination with the male genitalia structures. Female genitalia and other structures and ratios have very limited application for the species identification. Most species are very similar to each other externally and have the same set of sclerites in vesica and differ in their relative length and width. The needle-shaped sclerite is most often reduced.
Morphological studies and molecular-based analyses showed that A. lucorum, A. malaisei, A. nigronasutus, and A. nigrovirens are junior synonyms of A. spinolae. This species has extensive color variation, but it is not unique within Miridae. For example, the widespread Palearctic species of Lygus also have the significant variation in coloration combined with very low variation of the mitochondrial markers (
Some other green-colored species are also potential synonyms of A. spinolae, which can be tested in the future. The first of them is A. watajii. Although there are COI, 16S rRNA and 28S rRNA known for this species, the molecular data showed ambiguous results regarding the relationship of A. spinolae and A. watajii. There is a COI sequence for A. rhamnicola in Genbank obtained for the barcoding project in Germany (
Apolygus limbatus is also a trans-Palearctic species. Our studies showed that it can comprise two separate species, one of them inhabiting only the European part of Palearctic and the second one is distributed in Asia. Our morphological studies showed that they have slight but consistent differences in the sclerotization of vesica. The phylogeny based on COI also showed that European and Asian specimens do not cluster together, and the nuclear markers are needed to test the species boundaries in the future.
Molecular data have been generated for 15 species of Apolygus. However, for many of them only COI, 16S rRNA, 18S rRNA and 28S rRNA were obtained. We found that mitochondrial markers can show a misleading phylogenetic topology, and the number of substitutions for 18S rRNA and 28S rRNA is insufficient to reliably test species relationships. Therefore, more variable nuclear markers, such as ITS1, should be used for intra- and interspecific studies in this genus. The present work can be a background for further phylogenetic studies within Apolygus.
Currently we record 13 Apolygus species from Russia with 11 of them known from East Asia only. Apparently, this number will increase, because there are specimens from at least two species which we could not reliably place to any known taxon.
Author Contributions. A.N.N. contributed to the conceptualization, data analyses, drawings, writing original draft and funding acquisition. All authors contributed to the visualization, data processing, and manuscript editing.
Funding. The field trips and molecular work were supported by the Russian Science Foundation (RSF) grant 23-24-00417. The collection used for this study and facilities was supported by the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Russian Federation 125012901042-9 and 0665-2019-0014.
Conflict of interests. The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Laboratory work and SEMs were completed using the equipment in the Core Facility Centre “Taxon” (ZIN). The specimens for this molecular studies were collected in the Kandalaksha Nature Reserve (Murmansk Province), Belogorye State Nature Reserve (Belgorod Province), Beshtaugorskiy Reserve (Stavropol Territory), Lazovsky State Nature Reserve, Sikhote-Alin Nature Reserve (Primorskiy Territory), Bureinskiy Nature Reserve, Bolshekhekhtsirskiy Nature Reserve (Khabarovsk Territory), Curonian Spit National Park (Kaliningrad Province), Nalychevo Nature Park (Kamchatka Territory), Teberda Nature Reserve (Karachay-Cherkessia Republic), Yuganskiy Nature Reserve (Khanty-Mansi Autonomous District), Shushenskiy Park, Sayano-Shushensky Nature Reserve (Krasnoyarsk Territory). We are grateful for the administration and stuff of those reserves for assisting us and our colleagues with the specimens collecting. We thank our colleagues who collected or loaned us the material for this study: Petr Kment (National Museum, Kunratice, Czech Republic), Dmitry Gapon, Maria Berlina, Kirill Fadeev, Fedor Konstantinov, Sergei Belokobylskij (ZIN), Nikolay Vinokurov (Institute for Biological Problems of Cryolithozone, Yakutsk), Vasiliy Anikin (Saratov State University), Alexandra Tokareva (Museum and Institute of Zoology, Polish Academy of Sciences), Artyom Ryabinin (Institute of Cytology and Genetics, Russian Academy of Sciences, Novosibirsk), Yuriy Sundukov, Larisa Sundukova, Tatyana Markova (Federal Scientific Center of the East Asia Terrestrial Biodiversity, Far East Branch of the Russian Academy of Science), Nikolay Simov (National Museum of Natural History, Sofia, Bulgaria), Viktor Golub (Voronezh State University, Voronezh Province), Vladimir Dubatolov (Institute of Systematics and Ecology of Animals, Novosibirsk), Dmitry Vitenko (Saint Petersburg State University), Viktor Aleksanov (State Budgetary Institution of Kaluga Region “Parks Directorate”, Kaluga, Russia). We are grateful to Ruth Salas and Jessica Ware (American Museum of Natural History, USA) for providing us the photographs of the Apolygus spinolae and A. lucorum paralectotypes. We also thank Veronica Tyts (University of California, Riverside, USA) for assistance with the molecular work and collection of specimens. We thank two reviewers whose comments and corrections helped to improve the manuscript. We are greatful for Michael Schwarts (Agriculture & Agri-Food Canada, Canadian National Collection of Insects, Ottawa, Canada) for revising the paper.
Figures S1–S27
Data type: .pdf
Explanation notes: This file includes Figures S1–S27 with the additional phylogenies and digital images of the vouchers for the molecular work.
File S1
Data type: .pdf
Explanation notes: This file includes the list of collection events for all Apolygus specimens examined for this study.
Tables S1–S6
Data type: .pdf
Explanation notes: This file includes the Tables S1–S6 with the additional information: list of the genbank accestion numbes for all vouchers used for the molecular works, list of the primers used for PCR and PCR protocols, supports for the main clades in the resulted phylogenies, results of the species delimitation analyses, interspecific and intraspecific p-distances for the Apolygus species, list of the specimens corresponding to each haplotype revealed in this study.