Research Article |
|
Corresponding author: Alberto Sánchez-Vialas ( alberto.alytes@gmail.com ) Corresponding author: José L. Ruiz ( euserica@hotmail.com ) Academic editor: Vinicius S. Ferreira
© 2026 Alberto Sánchez-Vialas, Arnau Calatayud-Mascarell, José L. Ruiz, Ernesto Recuero, Mario García-París.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
|
Abstract
The evolutionary dynamics of morphological traits can often blur the boundaries between interspecific divergence and intraspecific variability, complicating species recognition. This study investigates the variation in secondary sexual traits and the existence of potential speciation processes within what is now considered Berberomeloe insignis (Coleoptera: Meloidae), an endangered blister beetle taxon endemic to southeastern Spain. Despite previous evidence of substantial genetic and phenotypic differentiation, key characters as the morphological variation in secondary sexual traits, such as antennomeres, remain unexplored. Using geometric morphometrics, we analyzed the shape variation of male and female antennomeres VII–XI across all previously recognized lineages of B. insignis. Our results reveal significant morphological differentiation, particularly in antennomeres VII, IX, and XI, which correlate broadly with genetic lineages. Based on the study of newly recorded populations, we confirm that cephalic coloration patterns correspond with mitochondrial lineages, further supporting the existence of geographic lineage differentiation within what was previously considered B. insignis. Climatic niche modeling indicates low climatic niche overlap between the isolated western lineage and the remaining lineages, which also show relatively low to moderate overlap, suggesting that ecological factors could have contributed to the divergence among them. These findings underscore the intricate interplay of genetics and ecology, highlighting the importance of integrating multiple data sources for accurate species delimitation. Based on our results, we describe B. nazari sp. nov. and B. insignis trisanguinatus ssp. nov. reflecting the evolutionary history of this group.
geometric morphometrics, morphology, sexual dimorphism, taxonomy, endemism, Iberian Peninsula, new taxa
Morphological diversification has often been associated with lineage isolation (
Lineages inhabiting the southern European Mediterranean Peninsulas have gained significant attention for their remarkable genetic and morphological diversity, observed at both inter- and intraspecific levels. This diversity often follows the pattern of “southern richness and northern purity” (
One example of this pattern is represented by the genus Berberomeloe Bologna, 1988 (Coleoptera: Meloidae), a group of giant blister beetles following the “southern richness” pattern in the Iberian Peninsula. Due to its large size, diurnal activity, conspicuous coloration, and pharmacological properties, Berberomeloe is particularly popular in rural areas of Spain (see
Southeastern Spain, from eastern Málaga to southeastern Alicante, is the most species-rich area for Berberomeloe, including six parapatric (and in some cases sympatric;
Currently, the four main mitochondrial lineages of B. insignis are known to be diagnosable only by cephalic coloration, as no other morphological differences have been identified (
Secondary sexual traits in insects, such as male-specific morphology, often evolve rapidly due to sexual selection, potentially contributing to reproductive isolation and aiding species delimitation (
Based on the published molecular results by
We hypothesize that (1) molecular divergence and morphological differentiation in secondary sexual traits would change at the same rate, potentially indicating completed speciation, and (2) hybridization between lineages in Berberomeloe may limit morphological divergence, leading to the formation of intermediate phenotypes. Given the threats that Berberomeloe faces due to habitat destruction and vulnerability to greenhouse expansions (
To confirm the molecular identification of the five newly recorded populations (Escúllar, Felix, Torre de Maro, Río de la Miel, and Jete), we sequenced one to four specimens from each locality (Table
Specimens used for molecular analyses. Locality, voucher number, and GenBank accession codes are provided.
| Species of Berberomeloe | Locality in Spain | Voucher/catalog number | GenBank#CoxI | GenBank#16S |
| B. insignis trisanguinatus | Almería: Escúllar | ASV2402/MNCN_Ent 429909 | PV034824 | |
| B. insignis trisanguinatus | Almería: El Puntal | BiMAB181/ MNCN_Ent 325382 | KC853087 | KC853066 |
| B. insignis trisanguinatus | Almería: El Puntal | BiMAB184/ MNCN_Ent 325383 | KC853088 | KC853067 |
| B. insignis trisanguinatus | Almería: El Puntal | BiMAB193/- | MN252816 | MN252646 |
| B. insignis trisanguinatus | Almería: El Puntal | BiMAB194/- | MN252817 | MN252647 |
| B. insignis trisanguinatus | Almería: El Puntal | BiMAB195/- | MN252818 | MN252648 |
| B. insignis trisanguinatus | Almería: El Puntal | BiMAB196/- | MN252819 | MN252649 |
| B. insignis trisanguinatus | Almería: Peñas Negras-Los Perales | BiMAB192/ MNCN_Ent 325384 | MN252815 | MN252645 |
| B. insignis trisanguinatus | Almería: 4.5 km south of Zurgena | BiMAB182/ MNCN_Ent 325385 | KC853086 | KC853065 |
| B. insignis trisanguinatus | Almería: Tabernas | ASV18010/ MNCN_Ent 325386 | OQ151517 | OQ151611 |
| B. insignis trisanguinatus | Almería: Tabernas | ASV19009/ MNCN_Ent 325387 | OQ151521 | OQ151615 |
| B. insignis trisanguinatus | Almería: Tabernas | ASV19010/ MNCN_Ent 325388 | OQ151522 | OQ151616 |
| B. insignis insignis | Murcia: Las Palas | ASV18023/ MNCN_Ent 325396 | OQ151620 | |
| B. insignis insignis | Murcia: Mazarrón | ASV18040/ MNCN_Ent 325397 | OQ151527 | OQ151621 |
| B. insignis insignis | Murcia: Morata | ASV18013/ MNCN_Ent 325398 | OQ151520 | OQ151614 |
| B. insignis insignis | Murcia: Águilas | ASV18014/MNCN_Ent 429879 | OQ151526 | |
| B. nazari | Granada: La Garnatilla | ASV18041/MNCN_Ent 429968 | OQ151523 | OQ151617 |
| B. nazari | Granada: La Garnatilla | ASV18042/MNCN_Ent 429969 | OQ151524 | OQ151618 |
| B. nazari | Granada: La Garnatilla | ASV18043/MNCN_Ent 429970 | OQ151525 | OQ151619 |
| B. nazari | Granada: Polopos | ASV18009/MNCN_Ent 429971 | OQ151516 | OQ151610 |
| B. nazari | Granada: Jete | ASV21001/MNCN_Ent 429976 | PV034818 | PV034800 |
| B. nazari | Granada: Jete | ASV21002/MNCN_Ent 429975 | PV034819 | PV034801 |
| B. nazari | Granada: Jete | ASV21003/MNCN_Ent 429973 | PV034820 | PV034802 |
| B. nazari | Granada: Jete | ASV21004/MNCN_Ent 429974 | PV034817 | PV034799 |
| B. nazari | Málaga: Río de la Miel | ASV21008/MNCN_Ent 429964 | PV034822 | PV034804 |
| B. nazari | Málaga: Torre de Maro | ASV21006/MNCN_Ent 429963 | PV034821 | PV034803 |
| B. nazari | Málaga: Río de la Miel | ASV2201/MNCN_Ent 429966 | PV034815 | PV034797 |
| B. nazari | Málaga: Río de la Miel | ASV2202/MNCN_Ent 429967 | PV034816 | PV034798 |
| B. lineage C2 | Almería: El Sabinar | ASV18011/MNCN_Ent 429949 | OQ151518 | OQ151612 |
| B. lineage C2 | Almería: Las Marinas | ASV18012/MNCN_Ent 429948 | OQ151519 | OQ151613 |
| B. lineage C2 | Almería: Felix | ASV2401/MNCN_Ent 429911 | PV034823 |
Genomic DNA was extracted from femoral muscular tissue using the Qiagen DNeasy extraction kit (Qiagen, Valencia, CA, USA). Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) was used to amplify CoxI and 16S using the set of primers LCO 1490/COI-H (
Sequences were reviewed, assembled, and edited in Geneious v.11.0.18 and aligned using MAFFT (
Additionally, a phylogenetic network was generated using SplitsTree v.6.3.41 (
We also considered the nuclear ITS2 allele data from
To investigate a possible effect of isolation by distance (IBD) within B. insignis sensu lato, we used the CoxI dataset to derive a genetic distance matrix (Table SS1) using MEGA X (
Geographic distances were calculated from georeferenced locality data (Table
To assess the correlation between geographic and genetic distances, we conducted Mantel tests using the mantel function from the R package Vegan (
A total of 182 specimens were examined, including 168 housed at the Museo Nacional de Ciencias Naturales (MNCN-CSIC, Madrid, Spain) and 14 at the Museo de Ciencias Naturales de Tenerife (MUNA, Sta. Cruz de Tenerife, Spain). Of these, 126 specimens were preserved in ethanol, while 56 were dry-preserved (Table S2). Additionally, detailed photographs of the holotype (by monotypy) of Meloe insignis Charpentier, 1818, deposited at the Museum für Naturkunde-Berlin (
Ethanol-preserved and dry-mounted specimens were examined under a stereomicroscope. Selected male specimens were rehydrated in water prior to genitalia extraction. For dry-mounted specimens, male genitalia were mounted on a cardboard using dimethylhydantoin formaldehyde (DMHF) resin and pinned adjacent the specimen. In ethanol-preserved specimens, male genitalia were stored in an Eppendorf tube filled with 96% ethanol, kept within the vial of the specimen. Measurements were taken from images captured using a Leica MZ16A stereomicroscope, fitted with a Leica DFC550 camera and processed with the software LAS v.4.3. Terminology for the male genitalia follows
We conducted geometric morphometric analyses (GM) focusing on the shape variation of the last five antennomeres (VII–XI) in relation to four mitochondrial lineages of Berberomeloe insignis identified by
Geographic records of B. insignis were compiled from previously published data (mainly
The potential geographic distribution ranges of the five different lineages of Berberomeloe insignis were inferred using MaxEnt 3.4.1 (
Potential ecological interchangeability among the different lineages within the two main clades was evaluated by measuring niche overlap using Schoener’s D-metrics (
Distinguishing between interspecific and intraspecific variation is a challenging task (
The newly generated Cox1 (657 bp) and 16S (510 bp) sequences have been deposited in GenBank (Table
Phylogenetic relationships and geographic distribution of Berberomeloe insignis sensu lato. The mitochondrial phylogenetic tree (Cox1 and 16S) and the ITS2 allelic network (adapted from
The phylogenetic network generated using SplitsTree revealed a well-defined and cohesive lineage (C) encompassing populations from Granada, Málaga (C1), and western Almería (C2). Within this lineage, the specimens from western Almería showed a relatively genetic differentiation from western areas (C1). The clade C is clearly separated from the others by a long branch, indicating limited interaction with other lineages. In contrast, the remaining clades (B) exhibited a more intricate pattern, with high genetic differentiation but multiple reticulations (nexus points) within the network, suggesting extensive historical gene flow among them (Fig.
The Mantel test results revealed low correlation between geographic and genetic distances across populations of Berberomeloe insignis sensu lato. Although the correlation was statistically significant (Mantel statistic r = 0.1165, P = 0.033), it remained notably weak (Fig.
GM analyses of male antennomeres revealed a complex pattern of morphological variation (Figs
Deformation grids showing shape variation of Berberomeloe antennomere XI in males from Tabernas, lineage B2 (A) and Jete, lineage C1 (B). C, D Principal component analysis of antennomere XI for both sexes. Black polygon: mtDNA clade B1; red polygon: mtDNA clade B2; green polygon: mtDNA clade C2; blue polygon: mtDNA clade C1.
In females, antennomeres showed substantial overlap among clades, except for the Murcia clade (B1), which exhibited clear differentiation from the others (Fig.
PCA for males indicated that PC1 and PC2 accounted for 45.37% and 14.87% of the variability for antennomere XI, 65.63% and 22.69% for antennomere X, 54.97% and 27.81% for antennomere IX, 67.65% and 19.75% for antennomere VIII, and 46.18% and 26.13% for antennomere VII. For females, PC1 and PC2 explained 31.9% and 21.9% of the variability for antennomere XI, 77.44% and 11.19% for antennomere X, 72.37% and 14.89% for antennomere IX, 66.16% and 18.66% for antennomere VIII, and 62.87% and 20.11% for antennomere VII.
In summary, all major clades (B1, B2, C1) can be distinguished based on variation in antennomeres, with the exception of the potentially hybrid populations represented by the mitochondrial subclade C2 (Campo de Dalías and southern Sierra de Gádor), which consistently exhibit significant overlap with other clades.
Head coloration patterns of the newly reported specimens are geographically congruent with their corresponding mitochondrial lineages (
The species distribution models (SDMs) performed well for the lineages of B. insignis, as indicated by high Area Under the Curve (AUC) values: Murcia (clade B1): AUC = 0.962; Eastern Almería and Pasillo de Fiñana Valley (clade B2): AUC = 0.950; Málaga, Granada, and the southwestern edge of Almería (clade C1): AUC = 0.983; Campo de Dalías and southern Sierra de Gádor (clade C2): AUC = 0.985. In addition, the SDM for all main lineages of B. insignis sensu lato yielded an AUC of 0.926.
The environmental variables that contributed most to the models varied by clade: for clade B1, bio16 (51.4%) and bio14 (15.9%); for clade B2, bio16 (50.2%) and bio15 (30.5%); for clade C1, bio6 (50.6%) and bio7 (25.3%); and for clade C2, bio14 (30.9%) and bio7 (30.4%). Across all lineages of B. insignis, bio16 (61.3%) and bio15 (14%) were the primary contributing variables.
Niche overlap, measured using Schoener’s D-metric, was low between clade C1 (Málaga, Granada, and the southwestern edge of Almería) and other clades, and relatively low to moderate among the different clades of B. insignis sensu lato (Table 2). All comparisons were statistically significant, indicating that the lineages are not ecologically interchangeable (Figs S1–S6).
According to this new taxonomic framework, since B. insignis sensu lato includes two candidate species, it is necessary to assign the original name to one of the two species. Charpentier (
Holotype of Meloe insignis (currently Berberomeloe insignis). Original drawing of the type specimen from Charpentier’s (1818) description, sourced from the Biodiversity Heritage Library (https://www.biodiversitylibrary.org) (A). Frontal (B) and dorsal (C) views of the type of B. insignis housed at the Museum für Naturkunde Berlin, with labels shown in (C). Photographs: Ivo Jurisch, Museum für Naturkunde Berlin.
However, the situation becomes more complex for the populations of the lineage C2. Historical genetic introgression appears to explain the observed cyto-nuclear discordance in the populations from southwestern Almería (lineage C2). While mitochondrial DNA places these populations closer to the westernmost lineage (C1), nuclear ITS2 data aligns them more closely with the central-eastern Almería and Murcia populations (lineage B). Although geographically restricted to a small area in southern Almería, specimens from lineage C2 exhibit broad morphological variation, overlapping with their parapatric lineages. C2 populations are nevertheless distinguishable by a singular head coloration (see
The current taxonomic catalogue for B. insignis should be modified with the following descriptions and diagnosis:
Meloe insignis Charpentier in Germar, 1818: 258. Type locality: “Spanien”
Berberomeloe insignis (Charpentier, 1818): García-París, 1998: 99.
Meloe insignis Charpentier in Germar, 1818: 258. Type locality: “Spanien”
Berberomeloe insignis (Charpentier, 1818): García-París, 1998: 99.
Detailed descriptions of B. insignis s.l. were provided by
Berberomeloe insignis insignis can be differentiated from other taxa of the B. insignis species group by the presence of (1) two symmetric red- to orange-colored blotches over the temples that do not extend anteromedially as a lobate projection above the ocular margin; (2) absence of a V- or Y-shaped mark on the frons; (3) strongly elongated antennomeres in both sexes; (4) elongated male genitalia (Fig.
Berberomeloe insignis insignis. Male from Mazarrón, Murcia (A). Male from las Palas, Murcia (B). Male antennomeres IV–XI from a specimen from Las Palas, Murcia (C). Male genitalia of specimen MNCN_Ent 429864 from 1.5 km northeast of Morata, Murcia (D–F): ventral and lateral views of the gonoforceps (D, E), and lateral view of the aedeagus (F); scale bar: 1 mm.
From B. insignis trisanguinatus ssp. nov. (B2 lineage) it can be readily differentiated by the lack of the red V- or Y-shaped mark on the frons, different shape of male antennomeres VII–XI and more elongated female antennomeres VII–XI. From B. nazari sp. nov. it differs by a more regular shape of the marks of the temples, that do not extend to the frons bordering the upper ocular margin area, by different shape of male antennomeres VII–XI, and by more elongated antennomeres VII–XI in female. The most phenotypically similar populations to Berberomeloe insignis insignis are those from Campo de Dalías and southern Sierra de Gádor (lineage C2) from which it can be distinguished by the closer proximity of the blotches on the temples in the occipital area, distinct shapes of male antennomeres VIII–XI, and by the more elongated antennomeres VII–XI in female (Table S5).
Females have the last exposed abdominal tergite VIII rounded, not emarginated at its posterior margin, with antennomeres IX, VII, and V less widened apically, and the last antennomere wider in its apical area.
According to the available distribution data, this subspecies is endemic to the province of Murcia, primarily inhabiting coastal and subcoastal areas from sea level to 630 m a.s.l.. Some populations extend inland up to 30 km from the coast, particularly around Sierra de Carrascoy (Majal Blanco) and South to the city of Murcia (Algezares) (
We have revised the coordinates of “Algezares” as reported by
It has been found in sympatry with Berberomeloe majalis (Linnaeus, 1758) in the surroundings of Isla Plana (authors pers. obs.).
Holotype: Male, labeled: España, Escúllar, Almería, 37°10'51.4"N 2°44'31.6"W, 18-IV-2024, Sánchez Vialas, A. leg. [white label, printed]; MNCN_Ent 429880 [white label, printed]; Holotypus, Berberomeloe insignis trisanguinatus Sánchez-Vialas, Calatayud-Mascarell, Ruiz, Recuero & García-París des. 2025 [white label, printed]. Preserved in absolute ethanol at the Entomological collection of the Museo Nacional de Ciencias Naturales, Madrid. — Paratypes (29 exx, all held at the Entomological collection of the Museo Nacional de Ciencias Naturales, Madrid): 7 males and 14 females labeled: España, Almería, Tabernas, alrededores, 389 m, 37°05'43.04"N 02°05'15.07"W, 29-III-2008, E. Recuero and C. Settanni leg. [white label, printed]; BI264, 267, 270, 272, 277, 283, 284, 226, 263, 265, 268, 269, 273–276, 278–282 [white label, handwritten; 7 males and 14 females, respectively]; MNCN_Ent 429901, MNCN_Ent 429900, MNCN_Ent 429897, MNCN_Ent 429899, MNCN_Ent 429896, MNCN_Ent 429895, MNCN_Ent 429898, MNCN_Ent 429890, MNCN_Ent 429882, MNCN_Ent 429881, MNCN_Ent 429883, MNCN_Ent 429892, MNCN_Ent 429891, MNCN_Ent 429894, MNCN_Ent 429887, MNCN_Ent 429889, MNCN_Ent 429886, MNCN_Ent 429884, MNCN_Ent 429888, MNCN_Ent 429885, MNCN_Ent 429893 (preserved in ethanol). – 1 male, labeled: España, Almería, 10 km E Tabernas, 489 m, 37°04'50.1"N 02°19'21.4"W, 28-III-2008, E. Recuero and C. Settanni leg. [white label, printed]; MNCN_Ent 429902 [white label, printed] (preserved in ethanol). – 6 females, labeled: España, Almería, Las Casillas de Atochares, 36°52'53.0"N 02°10'13.2"W, 30-III-2008, E. Recuero and C. Settanni leg. [white label, printed]; BI315–318, BI334–335 [white label, handwritten]; MNCN_Ent 429903–429908 [white label, printed] (females, preserved in ethanol). – 1 male, labeled: España, Almería, Escúllar, 37°10'51.4"N 2°44'31.6"W, 18-IV-2024, Sánchez Vialas, A. leg. [white label, printed]; ASV2402 [white label, handwritten]; MNCN_Ent 429909 [white label, printed] (preserved in ethanol). All paratypes labeled: Paratypus, Berberomeloe insignis trisanguinatus Sánchez-Vialas, Calatayud-Mascarell, Ruiz, Recuero & García-París des. 2025 [white label, printed].
The specific epithet “trisanguinatus” is a Latin adjective meaning “three-blooded”, referring to the species’ distinctive cephalic phenotype. This taxon is unique within the genus Berberomeloe for its three conspicuous red blotches on the head: a V- or Y-shaped blotch at the center of the frons and two symmetrical blotches on the temples.
Head-to-elytron length (frons anterior margin to elytra posterior extreme): 16.3 mm. Total length (including abdomen): 42.5 mm. Maximum width (distance between elytra outer extremes): 9.2 mm. Body robust. Voluminous and elongated abdomen. Reduced and convex elytra, hindwings absent. Coloration black all over body and appendages except for head, which features two symmetrical red to orange blotches over temples, and a single, isolated smaller Y-shaped blotch at center of frons (Fig.
Berberomeloe insignis trisanguinatus ssp. nov. Female from Tabernas, Almería (A). Male Holotype (MNCN_Ent 429880) from Escúllar, Sierra de los Filabres, Almería (B). Male antennomeres IV–XI from a specimen from Tabernas (C). Male genitalia (D–F): ventral view of the gonoforceps (D) (right: holotype; left: specimen from Tabernas, Almería); lateral view of the gonoforceps (E) (right: holotype; left: specimen from Tabernas, Almería); lateral view of the aedeagus (F) (right: holotype; left: specimen from Tabernas, Almería); scale bar: 1 mm.
Body length (frons to posterior margin of elytra) ranges from 9 to 24 mm. Red-orange mark on frons varies in shape, ranging from a V- to Y-like.
Females last abdominal ventrite VIII rounded, not emarginated at its posterior margin, with antennomeres V, VII, and IX less widened apically, and last antennomere XI less slender in its inner apical portion than in males.
Berberomeloe insignis trisanguinatus ssp. nov. can be readily differentiated from other taxa of the B. insignis species group by the presence of (1) two symmetric red- to orange-colored blotches over the temples that do not extend anteromedially as a lobate projection above the ocular margin, and (2) a single, isolated, V- or Y-shaped mark on the frons (Fig.
Berberomeloe insignis trisanguinatus can also be differentiated from B. nazari sp. nov. by the different shape of male antennomeres VII, IX and XI, which are more elongated in B. insignis trisanguinatus. From B. insignis insignis it can be distinguished by the shape of female and male antenomeres VII–XI, which are shorter in B. insignis trisanguinatus compared to B. insignis insignis. Beyond the presence of a frontal red blotch on the head, the only morphological difference between B. insignis trisanguinatus and the specimens of the C2 lineage is found in the male antennomere VII (Table S5).
Endemic to the province of Almería. Populations of B. insignis trisanguinatus are distributed across eastern and central Almería, with coastal and inland populations, particularly in the Tabernas Desert and Pasillo de Fiñana region, situated between Sierra Nevada and Sierra de los Filabres. It is an element of low to mid altitudes, with an altitudinal range from sea level to 1800 m a.s.l. It mainly occupies the thermo-Mediterranean bioclimatic level and, occasionally, extends into the meso-Mediterranean zone, and more rarely into the supra-Mediterranean zone, in the latter cases in areas of high temperature and low rainfall. The dominant ombroclimate in its distribution area is semi-arid (250–400 mm of average annual rainfall) (e.g.,
Berberomeloe insignis trisanguinatus has been found in sympatry with B. indalo in the following localities of Almería: El Puntal (
Holotype: Male, labeled: Spain, Málaga, Río de la Miel, 36°47'40.9"N 03°46'24.5"W, 16-IV-2024, Sánchez Vialas, A. leg. [white label, printed]; MNCN_Ent 429955 [white label, printed]; Holotypus, Berberomeloe nazari Sánchez-Vialas, Calatayud-Mascarell, Ruiz, Recuero, & García-París des. 2025 [white label, printed]. Preserved in absolute ethanol at the Entomological collection of the Museo Nacional de Ciencias Naturales, Madrid. — Paratypes (34 exx, all held at the Entomological collection of the Museo Nacional de Ciencias Naturales, Madrid): 1 male and 5 females. labeled: Málaga, Río de la Miel, 36°47'40.9"N 03°46'24.5"W, 16-IV-2024, Sánchez Vialas, A. leg. [white label, printed]; MNCN_Ent 429956–429961 [white label, printed] (preserved in ethanol). – 1 male and 1 female, labeled: Málaga, Río de la Miel, 36°47'32.23"N 03°46'09.81"W, 22-V-2021, J. L. Ruiz leg. [white label, printed]; MNCN_Ent 429965 [white label, printed] (preserved together in ethanol). – 3 females, labeled: Málaga, Río de la Miel, 36°47'32.23"N 03°46'09.81"W, 22-V-2021, J. L. Ruiz leg. [white label, printed]; MNCN_Ent 429966, 429967, 429964 [white label, printed]; ASV2201, ASV2202, ASV21008 [white label, handwritten] (preserved in ethanol). – 1 male, labeled: Málaga, Torre de Maro, 07-IV-2021, J. L. Ruiz leg. [white label, printed]; MNCN_Ent 429963 [white label, printed]; ASV21006 [white label, handwritten] (preserved in ethanol). – 2 males, labeled: Granada, Jete, 36°47'34.93"N 03°39'05.73"W, 09-III-2021, Sánchez Vialas, A. leg. [white label, printed]; ASV21003-ASV21004 [white label, handwritten]; MNCN_Ent 429973–429974 [white label, printed] (males, preserved in ethanol). – 1 male, labeled: Jete, Granada, 36°48'11.60"N 03°39'34.50"W, 16-III-2020, François, A. leg. [white label, printed]; ASV21001 [white label, handwritten]; MNCN_Ent 429976 [white label, printed] (preserved in ethanol). – 1 female, labeled: Jete, Granada, 36°48'11.60"N 03°39'34.50"W, 10-IV-2020, François, A. leg. [white label, printed]; MNCN_Ent 429975 [white label, printed]; ASV21002 [white label, handwritten] (preserved in ethanol). – 1 female, labeled: Jete, Granada, 36°48'11.60"N 03°39'34.50"W, 09-IV-2021, François, A. leg. [white label, printed]; MNCN_Ent 429962 [white label, printed] (preserved in ethanol). – 1 female, labeled: Granada, 3 km southern Polopos, 36°45'48.48"N 03°18'07.61"W, 11-IV-2010, García-París, M. & Bologna, M.A. leg. [white label, printed]; MNCN_Ent 429971 [white label, printed] (preserved in ethanol). – 1 male, labeled: Granada, 4 km southern Polopos, 36°45'26.01"N 03°17'56.09"W, 11-IV-2010, García-París, M. & Bologna, M.A. leg. [white label, printed]; MNCN_Ent 429972 [white label, printed] (preserved in ethanol). – 6 males and 9 females, labeled: Granada, La Garnatilla to Lújar, 36°43'42.05"N 03°26'27"W, 06-V-2018, Calatayud, A. & Tena, J. leg. [white label, printed]; MNCN_Ent 429968 (shared among 13 specimens), MNCN_Ent 429969, MNCN_Ent 429970 [white label, printed] (preserved in ethanol). All paratypes labeled: ‘Paratypus, Berberomeloe nazari Sánchez-Vialas, Calatayud-Mascarell, Ruiz, Recuero, & García-París des. 2025’ [white labels, printed].
The specific epithet “nazari” refers to the Kingdom of Granada under the Nasrid dynasty (Banū Naṣr), the last Muslim dynasty to rule Al-Andalus (13th–15th century). The name highlights the historical and cultural significance of the region, as the species is distributed across Granada and the eastern limits of Málaga, areas that once formed part of the Nasrid domain.
Head-to-elytron length (frons anterior margin to elytra posterior extreme): 18.4 mm. Total length (including abdomen): 39 mm. Maximum width (distance between elytra outer extremes): 11.6 mm. Body robust. Voluminous and elongated abdomen. Reduced and convex elytra, hindwings absent. Coloration black all over body and appendages except for head, which features 2 symmetrical red to orange blotches over temples that extends into frons (but not reaching frons midline) after bordering the upper ocular margin area (Fig.
Berberomeloe nazari sp. nov. Dorsal and dorsolateral views of the same specimen from Lújar, Granada (A, B). Male antennomeres IV–XI from a specimen from La Garnatilla to Lújar (C). Male genitalia (D–F): ventral view of the gonoforceps (D) (right: holotype; left: specimen from La Garnatilla, Granada); lateral view of the gonoforceps (E) (right: holotype; left: specimen from La Garnatilla, Granada); lateral view of the aedeagus (F) (right: holotype; left: specimen from La Garnatilla, Granada); scale bar: 1 mm.
Body length (frons to posterior margin of elytra) from 11 to 22 mm. Female last abdominal ventrite VIII rounded, not emarginated at its posterior margin, with antennomeres V, VII, and IX less widened apically, and last antennomere not dentate in its inner apical portion.
Berberomeloe nazari sp. nov. can be readily differentiated from other taxa of the B. insignis species group by the presence of (1) two symmetric red- to orange-colored blotches on the temples, each with its inner margin extending anteromedially as a lobate projection above the ocular margin, partially approaching the frons but not reaching the midline, which remains entirely black, (2) the absence of a V- or Y-shaped mark on the frons, and (3) male antennomere XI wide and notched in its posterior margin (Fig.
See accounts of B. insignis insignis, B. insignis trisanguinatus for morphological comparisons with this taxon. No additional morphological differences were observed between B. nazari and the specimens belonging to the C2 lineage.
Berberomeloe nazari ranges from Torre de Maro (Nerja) in eastern Málaga to the western border of Almería. This species generally occupies highly rugged terrain, characteristic of the Sierra de la Contraviesa, Sierra de Lújar, the southern boundary of the Sierra de la Almijara, and the southern slopes of Sierra Nevada (Fig.
(45 exx). 5 males, 1 female, labeled: S. Felix, Almería, Spain, 36°51'45.0"N 2°39'43.6"W, 17-IV-2024, Sánchez Vialas, A. leg. [white label, printed]; MNCN_Ent 429910–429915 [white label, printed]. – 12 males and 18 females, labeled: Spain, Almería, 5Km SW Las Marinas, 7 m, 36°42'65.00"N 02°40'17.3"W, 30-III-2008, E. Recuero & C. Settanni leg. [white label, printed]; BI013, 287, 292–294, 296, 298, 302, 304, 310, 312, 314, 001–006, 289–291, 295, 297, 299–301, 303, 305, 309, 313 [white label, handwritten]; MNCN_Ent 429916–429941, MNCN_Ent 429954, MNCN_Ent 429942–429944 [white label, printed] (preserved in ethanol). – 1 female, labeled: Faro del Sabinar-Las Marinas, 7 Km, Ctra a San Agustín, borde de las salinas, 1 m, 36°41'80.03"N 02°42'19.5"W, 29-III-2008, E. Recuero & C. Settanni leg. [white label, printed]; ASV18011 [white label, handwritten]; MNCN_Ent 429949 [white label, printed] (preserved in ethanol). – 2 females and 3 males, labeled: Faro del Sabinar-Las Marinas, 7 Km, Ctra a San Agustín, borde de las salinas, 1 m, 36°41'80.03"N 02°42'19.5"W, 29 March 2008, E. Recuero & C. Settanni leg. [white label, printed]; BI007–008, BI14–15 [white label, handwritten]; MNCN_Ent 429950–429953 [white label, printed] (preserved in ethanol). – 3 females and 1 male, labeled: 2Km W Las Marinas, Ctra a San Agustín, borde de las salinas, 13 m, 36°43'10.08"N 02°39'41.7"W, 29-III-2008, E. Recuero & C. Settanni leg. [white label, printed]; BI009–BI012 [white label, handwritten]; MNCN_Ent 429945–429948 [white label, printed] (preserved in ethanol).
These populations can be differentiated from other taxa by the presence of (1) two symmetric red- to orange-colored blotches over the temples that typically do not extend anteromedially as a lobate projection above the ocular margin (but see variability), (2) the absence of a clearly defined V- or Y-shaped mark on the frons, and (3) a relatively wide separation of both temples blotches at occiput level (Figs
Specimens of Berberomeloe lineage C2. Male (MNCN_Ent 429910) and female (MNCN_Ent 429911) from South of Felix, Almería (A, B, respectively). Male antennomeres IV–XI from a specimen from southwest of Las Marinas, Almería (C) (other individuals from the same population lack the apical notch on antennomere XI). Male genitalia (D–F): ventral (D) and lateral (E) views of the gonoforceps (right: specimen from Felix; left: specimen from El Ejido, 5 km southwestern of Las Marinas, Almería); lateral view of the aedeagus (F) (right: specimen from Felix; left: specimen from El Ejido, 5 km southwestern of Las Marinas, Almería); scale bar: 1 mm.
Phenotypic variability observed in Berberomeloe lineage C2 specimens from the same population at southern Felix (Sierra de Gádor, Almería). Specimen displaying two isolated orangish dots on either sides of the midline of the frons (A). Specimen with a similar pattern to A, but featuring an additional central, faint reddish blotch (B). Specimen where the small reddish blotches on either sides of the midline of the frons are connected to the main blotches of the temples (C). Specimen exhibiting the typical pattern observed in other populations, with no additional marks on the frontal surface (D).
See the account of B. insignis insignis for morphological comparisons with this lineage. Beyond the cephalic phenotype, no additional morphological differences were observed between B. nazari sp. nov. and B. insignis trisanguinatus ssp. nov.
Body length (frons to posterior border of elytra) from 10 to 25 mm. Shape of the last male antennomere highly variable, ranging from notched at the apex to unnotched. Although typically exhibits a consistent pattern in head phenotype, as shown in Fig.
Females have the last abdominal ventrite rounded, not emarginated at its posterior margin, with antennomeres V, VII, and IX less widened apically, and the last antennomere not dentate in its inner apical portion.
Lineage C2 is endemic to the province of Almería. It occurs between Campo de Dalías and the southern slopes of Sierra de Gádor. In Campo de Dalías, lineage C2 is found within the Natural Park of Punta Entinas-Sabinar, where it inhabits the sandy soils dominated by Juniperus phoenicea L. and Pistacia lentiscus L. (Fig.
Habitat of Berberomeloe lineage C2 populations (A, B, D). Paraje Natural Punta Entinas-Sabinar, Almería (A). Vacant lot surrounded by greenhouses and roads, in El Ejido region, North of Almerimar, Almería (B). Carcass of a specimen found in B (C). South of Felix, Sierra de Gádor, Almería (D).
Three specimens housed in the entomological collection of the MNCN (MNCN_Ent 65241, MNCN_Ent 232555–MNCN_Ent 232557), labeled as originating from “Alquian” exhibit phenotypes consistent with this lineage. Notably, the revised specimens housed at the MUNA and collected near El Alquián, in the Cabo de Gata region, belong to B. insignis trisanguinatus, suggesting that the “Alquian” labels of the MNCN specimens may either refer to a locality closer to Campo de Dalías or result from mislabeling. Several populations once recorded in Campo de Dalías are now extinct due to habitat destruction caused by the rapid and extensive expansion of greenhouses across the region.
Over recent decades, the rise of molecular techniques has catalyzed a wave of cryptic species discoveries, leading to a deeper understanding of biodiversity and speciation processes (
However, our study emphasizes the need to explore morphological diversification in species that may not be cryptic but are incompletely revised (
Our niche models show low overlap between B. nazari and other lineages, suggesting that it occupies a distinct climatic niche compared to the other taxa, including lineage C2 (Table 2; Figs S1, 18). The niche overlap among subspecies of B. insignis and the lineage C2 was relatively low to moderate, implying that while they share some climatic areas, notable ecological differences persist. Interestingly, despite phylogenetic and geographic proximity between B. insignis insignis and B. i. trisanguinatus, we did not observe specimens with intermediate characteristics that might indicate gene flow. This suggests that although these subspecies partially overlap in their climatic preferences, other factors, possibly ecological, behavioral, or genetic, may be maintaining their phenotypic differences near their contact zones.
In contrast, the absence of morphological differentiation and the presence of cyto-nuclear discordances in populations belonging to the lineage C2 highlight the need for further research to evaluate the extent of reproductive isolation among the involved lineages. At present, our data allow for outlining two alternative hypotheses that could explain the observed patterns of genetic and morphological discordances: (1) C2 populations would form a cohesive unit (sensu
The addition of the newly described taxa in this study makes the province of Almería a focal point for Berberomeloe diversity (Fig.
These findings present promising opportunities to study fine-scale ecological interactions across Berberomeloe lineages, particularly the potential roles of competitive exclusion or altitude-based habitat partitioning, highlighting the need for further research on the mechanisms shaping species coexistence. In this regard, to refine their distribution boundaries, further sampling is needed between Campo de Dalías/Sierra de Gádor and La Rábita/Laujar de Andarax to the west (eastern limit of B. nazari and western limit of lineage C2, minimum distance: 29 km), and between Campo de Dalías/Sierra de Gádor and El Palmer/Aguadulce to the east (western limit of B. i. trisanguinatus and eastern limit of lineage C2, minimum distance: 12 km), to assess whether gradual phenotypic transitions occur. Similarly, additional sampling is needed for populations between the known localities of B. i. trisanguinatus and B. i. insignis (minimum distance: 18 km).
The observed variation in male antennal morphology across distinct lineages of Berberomeloe suggests a potential role for sexual selection and reproductive isolation in driving divergence (
We identified distinct morphological extremes in male antennomere XI. Males of B. nazari have a wider antennomere, notched in its apical area (except some specimens of the C2 lineage), while B. i. insignis and B. i. trisanguinatus exhibit slender antennomeres, typically unnotched. Other antennomeres also show notable differences: X and VIII are significantly elongated in B. i. insignis compared to other taxa, while IX differs significantly across B. i. insignis, B. i. trisanguinatus, and B. nazari. Additionally, B. nazari has a shorter antennomere VII compared to the other taxa. Specimens from the C2 lineage exhibit a remarkable morphological variability in antennomeres XI and IX, along with head coloration, with antennal morphology overlapping that of B. i. trisanguinatus and B. nazari. A plausible explanation for the increased morphological variability in specimens from the C2 lineage is the existence of past or ongoing gene flow (
Male antennomeres V, VII, IX, and XI show a strongly dentate apical border on the inner side, covered by very short setae, distinct from the setae on the rest of the antennomere (authors pers. obs.). This specialized setation might play roles in searching for females, mate recognition, and courtship behaviors. In Berberomeloe, courtship begins with antennation, where males use their antennae to scrutinize the last female’s abdominal tergites through vibratory movements (
Female antennal morphology remains largely conserved, except in B. i. insignis, which shows marked differentiation in antennomeres VII, IX, and X. This elongation of antennomeres in females of B. i. insignis is particularly intriguing, especially given the apparent lack of selection pressures for antennal function in females, in contrast to the strong selection males face during mating.
The challenge of identifying and naming evolutionary units, whether intraspecific or at the species level, is crucial for raising awareness and ensuring the protection of distinct populations (
Conservation strategies should not only focus on taxa but also on protecting regions where key evolutionary processes – such as hybridization and local adaptation – drive and maintain biodiversity. Hybrid zones and other areas of ongoing diversification are crucial for preserving the mechanisms that generate evolutionary novelty and ecological resilience. This is particularly urgent in rapidly deteriorating landscapes such as southeastern Spain (
Our findings emphasize the urgent need for intensified taxonomic exploration, even for taxa previously considered well-documented. Regions like Campo de Dalías and Sierra de Gádor, which are under severe threat from greenhouse expansion, highlight the critical importance of precise taxonomic identification to inform effective conservation efforts (
We are grateful to Bernd Jäger (Museum für Naturkunde Berlin) for his invaluable comments on the historical type of Meloe insignis, and to Ivo Jurisch for kindly taking and sharing the photographs of it. We also thank Mercedes París and Alberto Rodríguez, curators of the entomological collections at the MNCN and MUNA, respectively, for their support in facilitating access to these collections. We are indebted to Alexandre François and Iñigo Esteban for providing samples and Jordi Tena, Marta Miñarro, and Helena Martínez for their assistance during field work. This study was funded by the project-grant PID2019-110243GB-100/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 (Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación) to MGP and by the MNCN Grant “Premio Cabrera 2018” to ASV.
Figures S1–S6
Data type: .docx
Explanation notes: Figure S1–S6. Environmental niche overlap comparisons.
Tables S1–S5
Data type: .zip
Explanation notes: Table SS1. Genetic distance matrix based on cox1 of Berberomeloe insignis sensu lato [xlsx file]. — Table S2. Data on specimens revised for qualitative and phenotypic traits [xlsx file]. — Table S3. Data on specimens used for antennomere morphometrics [xlsx file]. — Table S4. Recorded localities of the different taxa of Berberomeloe insignis sensu lato [xlsx file]. — Table S5. Summarised ANOVA results of the male and female antennomeres VII–XI between Berberomeloe lineages [docx file].