Research Article |
|
Corresponding author: Yoshinobu Matsushima ( mattuu901@eis.hokudai.ac.jp ) Academic editor: Martin Schwentner
© 2026 Yoshinobu Matsushima, Yasunori Kano, Keiichi Kakui.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Matsushima Y, Kano Y, Kakui K (2026) Phylogenetic relationships among four superfamilies in Tanaidacea (Peracarida) inferred from mitochondrial genomes. Arthropod Systematics & Phylogeny 84: 705-718. https://doi.org/10.3897/asp.84.e192470
|
Abstract
Tanaidacea contains about 1600 species across four superfamilies (Apseudoidea, Neotanaoidea, Paratanaoidea, and Tanaidoidea). Phylogenetic relationships among the four superfamilies had been investigated molecularly with one to several genes, or with transcriptome data, but not with mitochondrial genome (mitogenome) data. Mitogenome data were available only for Pseudotanais sp. (Paratanaoidea) and Arctotanais alascensis (Tanaidoidea). We sequenced and annotated a complete mitogenome sequence for Sinelobus kisui (Tanaidoidea) and nearly complete mitogenome sequences for Apseudes nipponicus, Apseudes ranma, Carpoapseudes spinigena (Apseudoidea), and Neotanais sp. (Neotanaoidea). We detected the typical two rRNA and 13 protein-coding genes (PCGs) in all five species, but failed to detect one to five tRNAs in each species. The gene orders of the four superfamilies differed from the pancrustacean ground pattern and from one another. In maximum-likelihood phylogenetic trees based on amino acid and nucleotide datasets for the 13 PCGs and two rRNA genes, Tanaidacea emerged as a weakly supported sister clade to Isopoda. Within Tanaidacea, a fully supported Apseudoidea was the sister group to a moderately supported clade comprising the other three superfamilies; in the latter clade, a weakly supported Tanaidoidea clade was successively sister to Paratanaoidea and then to Neotanaoidea. The mitogenome-based topology among the four superfamilies differed from previous topologies based on 18S rRNA or transcriptome data (Apseudoidea, (Paratanaoidea, (Neotanaoidea, Tanaidoidea))). This contradiction suggests possible effects of mito–nuclear discordance or long-branch attraction for Pseudotanais sp. and S. kisui.
Apseudoidea, mitochondrion, Neotanaoidea, Paratanaoidea, Tanaidoidea
Tanaidacea, one of the 12 extant orders in the crustacean superorder Peracarida, comprises about 1600 species (
Phylogenetic relationships among the superfamilies in Tanaidacea have received limited molecular investigation.
Mitochondrial genome (or mitogenome) data have not yet been used to investigate phylogenetic relationships among the four superfamilies in Tanaidacea. Although mitogenomes generally contain less phylogenetic information than transcriptomes, they still provide substantially more information than one or a few gene markers. In addition, mitogenomes can be sequenced from specimens preserved for taxonomic purposes (e.g., ethanol or formalin fixation), making them more available for data acquisition than transcriptomes, which require samples to be freshly collected, deep-frozen, or fixed in RNA-stabilization reagents.
At the onset of this study, mitogenome sequences were available for the tanaidoid Arctotanais alascensis (
We used individual specimens identified as the following five species collected around Japan: (1) Apseudes nipponicus Shiino, 1937 (Apseudoidea: Apseudidae), collected from an open-air experimental aquarium in the Shimoda Marine Research Center (University of Tsukuba), Shizuoka, Japan (for details, see
Total DNA was extracted from the whole body of each individual by using a NucleoSpin Tissue XS Kit (Macherey–Nagel, Germany). As seed sequences, previously determined partial COI sequences were used for A. ranma (LC791470;
For S. kisui, we designed primer pair Sk_COI_LF (5’-TCCTATAGGTGGGGGTGATCCAA TTTTATTTCAGC-3’) and Sk_COI_LR (5’-CTATATGCAGCCAAGGATAGCGGTGGGTAA ATTG-3’), by using Primer3Plus (
We used the purified amplicon of S. kisui and DNA extracted from each of the other four species in the whole-genome shotgun sequencing described below.
Whole-genome shotgun sequencing was performed by using 2 × 200 bp (A. nipponicus) and 2 × 150 bp (A. ranma, C. spinigena, and Neotanais sp.) paired-end reads on the DNBSEQ-G400 platform (MGI Tech, China) at Bioengineering Lab Co., Japan. Sequencing for S. kisui was performed by using 2 × 150 bp paired-end reads on the DNBSEQ-G400RS platform at Genome Read Inc., Japan. A total of 32,444,610 reads (2 × 4.8 Gbp) were obtained for A. nipponicus; 17,433,684 (2 × 3.4 Gbp) for A. ranma; 32,127,279 (2 × 4.7 Gbp) for C. spinigena; 34,957,034 (2 × 5.2 Gbp) for Neotanais sp.; and 6,228,917 (2 × 1.87 Gbp) for S. kisui.
The quality of the raw FASTQ files was initially assessed by using FastQC v0.12.0 (
Based on the assembled genomes of A. nipponicus, A. ranma, and Neotanais sp., we designed the following primers by using Primer3Plus and OlvTools (https://olvtools.com/tmvalue) to determine the sequences that remained unassembled after the procedure described above: ApnF (5’-GTATCCCTTTCCCGCCCTGCATCAC-3’) and ApnR (5’-CACACATTTCGTGCTCCCCTTTGATC-3’) for A. nipponicus; AprF (5’-CAGGATACACTTTTCGTGCTCCTCTTTG-3’) and AprR (5’-CCCCAGCCTCAGG TTTTAAATGAAG-3’) for A. ranma; and NeoF (5’-GTCGTGTTTTAGTTGCTTGGTCTGCACTTC-3’) and NeoR (5’-CCACGCAACACTATAACTGCCCAAATCATC-3’) for Neotanais sp. PCR amplification conditions with KOD ONE PCR Master Mix were as follows: for A. nipponicus, 45 cycles of 98°C for 10 s, 60°C for 5 s, and 68°C for 30 s; for A. ranma, 45 cycles of 98°C for 10 s, 55°C for 5 s, and 68°C for 30 s; and for Neotanais sp., 45 cycles of 98°C for 10 s and 68°C for 5 s. The amplified sequences were determined with a BigDye Terminator Kit v3.1 and a 3730 DNA Analyzer.
In addition to annotating the sequences of the five species determined in this study, we re-annotated the previously published mitogenome of Arctotanais alascensis (LC597489;
Genes that remained unidentified were identified manually through comparative alignments. The atp8 gene in A. ranma was determined by aligning the assembled genome with that of A. nipponicus, using MUSCLE (
The annotated mitochondrial genome sequences determined in this study have been deposited in the DDBJ/EMBL/GenBank databases under accession numbers LC923624–LC923628.
The concatenated dataset of 13 PCGs and two rRNAs included sequences from seven tanaidacean species, 71 non-tanaidacean peracarid species (41 amphipods, one cumacean, 25 isopods, one lophogastrid, two mysids, and one stygiomysid), and two non-peracarid species (one decapod and one euphausiacean) (Dataset 1; Table S1). Nucleotide sequences for the PCGs from all species except Pseudotanais sp. were translated into amino acid sequences according to the invertebrate mitochondrial genetic code. For Pseudotanais sp., translation with that code was not possible (the codon TAA translates as tyrosine rather than a stop codon;
The initial analysis with IQ-TREE detected extensive substitutional saturation in Dataset 1, particularly at third-codon positions in the PCGs. We thus do not present the results from Dataset 1, but instead analyzed two new datasets derived from Dataset 1. Dataset 2 included amino-acid sequences for the 13 PCGs and nucleotide sequences for the two rRNAs; that is, the aligned amino acid sequences were not back-translated to nucleotide sequences. Dataset 3 included nucleotide sequences for the first and second codon positions of the 13 PCGs and for the two rRNAs; that is, the nucleotides in the third codon position were removed from Dataset 1.
Dataset 2 comprised 4518 positions. The initial 15 partitions were merged into 13 optimal partitions by using ModelFinder with the MFP+MERGE option based on the BIC. Table S2 presents the final partitions and optimized substitution models. Dataset 3 comprised 8182 positions. The initial 28 partitions were merged into 17 optimal partitions by using ModelFinder with the MFP+MERGE option based on the BIC. Table S3 presents the final partitions and optimized substitution models. Methods for the ML analyses, branch support estimation, and drawing of the trees were as described above for Dataset 1.
To assess whether long-branch attraction (LBA) artifacts (
All sequence alignments used in this study have been deposited in the Figshare repository (
The assembled genomes for Apseudes nipponicus and Apseudes ranma were single contigs, 14,717 bp and 14,599 bp long, respectively (Fig.
Assembly graph and gene map for Carpoapseudes spinigena. A All contigs visualized by using Bandage (
For A. nipponicus and A. ranma, multiple bands were observed in electrophoresis of the PCR products amplified with specific primers, preventing identification of the target sequences. Cycle sequencing was thus not carried out for these bands. In Neotanais sp., a single band of approximately 900 bp was obtained. Sequencing of this product successfully determined only a ~600-bp portion, which completely overlapped with and was identical to the terminal region of the 14,746-bp contig mentioned above, including the primer region.
Nucleotide composition varied markedly among the species (Figs
In the five species, 13 PCGs and two rRNAs were identified. The complete set of 22 tRNAs was not identified, with the following being absent: trnI and trnM in both A. nipponicus (Fig.
Our re-annotation of the mitogenome of Arctotanais alascensis identified trnI, which was not identified in
Figure
Comparison of gene order among tanaidaceans and the hypothetical ancestral pattern for Pancrustacea (
While all tanaidaceans studied exhibited gene arrangements distinct from the pancrustacean ground pattern, several ancestral clusters were observed (Fig.
The ML trees based on Datasets 2 (Fig.
Maximum-likelihood (ML) phylogeny inferred from Dataset 2, including the amino acid sequences of the 13 PCGs and the nucleotide sequences of the two rRNAs (4518 characters; 13 partitions). A ML tree; double slashes indicate shortened branches. B Enlargement of part of the tree showing the true branch lengths leading to the three tanaidomorphs, Arctotanais alascensis, Pseudotanais sp., and Sinelobus kisui. Numbers near nodes are ultrafast bootstrap values (UFBoot). UFBoot ≥ 95%, indicating strong branch support, are in bold font. The scale bars indicate branch length in substitutions per site.
Maximum-likelihood (ML) phylogeny inferred from Dataset 3, including nucleotide sequences of the 13 PCGs (first and second codon positions only) and of the two rRNAs (8182 characters; 17 partitions). A ML tree; double slashes indicate shortened branches. B Enlargement of part of the tree showing the true branch lengths leading to the three tanaidomorphs, Arctotanais alascensis, Pseudotanais sp., and Sinelobus kisui. Numbers near nodes are ultrafast bootstrap values (UFBoot). UFBoot ≥ 95%, indicating strong branch support, are in bold font. The scale bars indicate branch length in substitutions per site.
The topology within Tanaidacea is identical between the two trees, with slight differences in branch support. The fully supported Apseudoidea clade was sister to the Tanaidomorpha clade (Tanaidoidea + Paratanaoidea + Neotanaoidea) with strong to moderate support (UFBoot = 99% for Dataset 2; 92% for Dataset 3). Within the latter clade, the neotanaoid Neotanais sp. lay outside a Paratanaoidea + Tanaidoidea clade, with weak (UFBoot = 76% for Dataset 2) or moderate (UFBoot = 92% for Dataset 3) support. The two tanaidoids formed a clade with high or low support (UFBoot = 97% for Dataset 2; 75% for Dataset 3). Our parametric simulations (Fig. S1) showed that a Paratanaoidea + Tanaidoidea clade was never reproduced in the simulated datasets (PB = 0%).
The branches leading to Pseudotanais sp. and S. kisui were markedly longer than those leading to the other five tanaidacean species (Figs
We determined the complete, circular mitogenome for S. kisui and partial mitogenomes containing the complete set of PCGs and rRNAs and most tRNAs for the other four species. Our attempt to Sanger-sequence the unassembled regions in three species failed. Based on our observation in Neotanais sp. that the PCR amplicon sequence was identical to the terminal region of the long contig, the unassembled regions are suggested to be composed of long repeat sequences. To determine the complete mitogenomes of the species for which we were unable to obtain circular mitogenomes, long-read sequencing technologies may be necessary.
Our (re-)annotation showed that no typical control region (CR) was present in the circular mitogenomes of A. alascensis and S. kisui, and that the region previously annotated as the CR in A. alascensis corresponds to part of rrnL (Fig.
We found that mitogenome gene order in Tanaidacea varies markedly among superfamilies and is highly divergent from the putative pancrustacean ground pattern. In addition, gene order stability varied considerably. Gene order was highly conserved in the two studied genera in Apseudoidea, whereas extensive rearrangements were evident in the two studied genera in Tanaidoidea.
Pseudotanais sp., A. alascensis, and S. kisui shared only one short cluster with the pancrustacean ground pattern, indicating a highly divergent mitogenome gene order. These three species, especially Pseudotanais sp. and S. kisui, exhibited much longer branch lengths than other tanaidaceans in our tree, which suggests that a marked acceleration in molecular evolutionary rates may have occurred in their most recent common ancestor. Previous studies have reported that higher substitution rates are correlated with elevated rates of gene rearrangements (
In the trees from Datasets 2 and 3, Tanaidacea was embedded in Mancoida as a strongly or fully supported clade, along with a cumacean species and a fully supported Isopoda clade. The sister taxon to Tanaidacea was not well resolved; an Isopoda + Tanaidacea clade appeared in both trees, but with only weak to moderate support. This sister relationship was recovered in a recent large-scale phylogenomic analysis (
The relationships we detected among tanaidacean superfamilies differ from those in three previous studies (
The long branches in Pseudotanais sp. and S. kisui might have been caused by a unique genetic code and a low-salinity habitat, respectively. In the mitogenome of Pseudotanais sp., TAA – normally a stop codon in the invertebrate mitochondrial genetic code – translates as tyrosine (
This is the first phylomitogenomic analysis incorporating all of the four superfamilies in Tanaidacea. However, the taxonomic coverage is still highly limited: our dataset contains only seven of around 1600 known species; 14 apseudoid families and 23 paratanaoid families are not represented. It is unclear whether the high evolutionary rate observed in Pseudotanais sp., evident as a remarkably long branch, is common in Paratanaoidea.
Conflict of interest. The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest in relation to this work.
Data Availability. The DNA sequence data underlying this study are available in the DDBJ/EMBL/GenBank databases under accession numbers LC923624–LC923628. All sequence alignments used in this study have been deposited in the Figshare repository (
We thank Jun Hashimoto for the opportunity to join TRV Nagasaki-maru cruise N295; Captain Hiroshi Yoshimura and the crew and researchers aboard the TRV Nagasaki-maru for help in collecting Neotanais sp.; Yasutaka Tsuchiya, Toshihiko Sato, Hideo Shinagawa, Yutaro Yamada, Daisuke Shibata, Atsuko Suzuki, Hiroaki Nakano, and Morihiko Tomatsuri for help in collecting A. nipponicus; Tsuyoshi Matsuda, Akira Ogushi, and Futoshi Kakizoe for help in collecting A. ranma; Hironori Komatsu for providing C. spinigena; Susumu Ohtsuka for help in collecting S. kisui; Hajime Ito for advice on long-PCR primer design; Samuel Abalde Lago for teaching analytical methods during the “Advanced Marine Biology Educational Program” at the Research Center for Marine Biology (RCMB), Tohoku University; Hiroaki Fukumori and the staff of RCMB for assistance; Satoshi Kawato, the developer of gbdraw Web App, for incorporating our requests; and Matthew H. Dick for reviewing the manuscript and editing our English. This study was funded in part by research grants from the Research Institute of Marine Invertebrates Foundation (KO2025-04, FY2025) and the Fujiwara Natural History Foundation (No. 17, FY2025); a JST SPRING grant JPMJSP2119; and KAKENHI grants JP19K06800, JP22H02681, JP23K23944, and JP26K09429 from the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS).
File S1
Data type: .pdf
Explanation notes: The Table shows the alignment lengths and optimal substitution models for two rRNA and 13 coding genes (initially partitioned into 41 subsets), Dataset 1. — The Figure shows the maximum-likelihood (ML) phylogeny for peracarid crustaceans, based on mitogenome sequences (11,650 characters from 13 protein-coding genes [PCGs] and two rRNA genes; Dataset 1). The dataset was initially partitioned into 41 partitions, representing the three individual codon positions for each of the 13 PCGs and the two separate rRNA genes. These subsets were optimized into a final scheme of 22 partitions. Numbers near nodes are ultrafast bootstrap values (UFBoot). — The Figure shows the assessment of long-branch attraction artifacts using parametric bootstrapping in Dataset 2 (comprising amino acid sequences for 13 PCGs and nucleotide sequences for two rRNAs).
Tables S1–S3
Data type: .zip
Explanation notes: Table S1. Source information for species included in the phylogenetic analyses. — Table S2. Alignment lengths and optimal substitution models for the two rRNA and 13 protein-coding genes included in phylogenetic analyses of Dataset 2. In the Length column, amino acid lengths are in bold font. — Table S3. Alignment lengths and optimal substitution models for the two rRNA and 13 protein-coding genes included in the phylogenetic analysis of Dataset 3.
Figure S1
Data type: .tif
Explanation notes: Assessment of long-branch attraction artifacts using parametric bootstrapping in Dataset 2 (comprising amino acid sequences for 13 PCGs and nucleotide sequences for two rRNAs).