Research Article |
Corresponding author: Zhi-Teng Chen ( 741208116@qq.com ) Academic editor: Ricardo Pérez-de la Fuente
© 2022 Zhi-Teng Chen.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
|
The larval stage is an essential part of the life history of stoneflies and can provide substantial biological and evolutionary information. However, well-preserved fossils of larvae are sparse. Herein, the larval morphology of a new extinct stonefly, Kachinoperla zwicki gen. et sp. nov., is described based on its exuvia in mid-Cretaceous Kachin amber from northern Myanmar (98.79±0.62 Ma). The new stonefly also represents a new family, Kachinoperlidae fam. nov. according to its unique characters. Kachinoperlidae can be distinguished from other stonefly families by the following larval characters: predaceous mouthparts, subequal glossae and paraglossae, subequal maxillary and labial palps, reduced apical maxillary palpomere, trapezoidal pronotum, banded and semicircular wing pads, invisible notal contour, absent thoracic gills, shortest first two tarsomeres, and strongly projected abdominal tergum 10. The morphological comparison and phylogenetic analysis suggested the new family as a basal lineage within Systellognatha. Evolutionary implications implied by the larval characters are also discussed.
Cenomanian, Kachin amber, Kachinoperla, Kachinoperlidae, phylogeny, Systellognatha
Plecoptera (stoneflies) is a basal hemimetabolous order of the “lower” Neoptera and includes 17 extant families and over 3800 extant species of aquatic insects distributed on all continents and most major islands except Antarctica (
Plecoptera is ancient, with its oldest representative extending into the Pennsylvanian (ca. 300 Ma) (
Larvae of stoneflies consist of a series of morphological characters very informative in species delimitation, higher-level classification, phylogeny, and inferring the evolutionary history of the order (
The Kachin amber studied herein was obtained from amber mines near Noije Bum (26°20’N, 96°36’E), Hukawng Valley, Kachin State of northern Myanmar. The geologic age was dated as earliest Cenomanian (98.79±0.62 Ma), early Late Cretaceous (
Photographs were taken with a Canon EOS 6D digital camera equipped with a Canon MP-E 65 mm 5× macro lens. Line drawings were produced with the aid of an SDPTOP SZM45 stereomicroscope and ADOBE ILLUSTRATOR CS6. Photographs and drawings were adjusted and optimized with ADOBE PHOTOSHOP CS6.
Two methods of morphological phylogenetic analysis were used to evaluate the systematic placement of the new stonefly, including parsimony and Bayesian inference. The character list and data matrix were partially derived from a previously published dataset in
The data matrix was subjected to a parsimony analysis with the program TNT 1.5 (
UFP – is used for the undetermined family in Perloidea. The following institutional abbreviation is used: ICJUST – Insect Collection of Jiangsu University of Science and Technology, Jiangsu Province, China. The following abbreviations of morphological characters are used: BL – body length (excluding antennae and cerci); HL – head length; HW – head width; ATL – antenna length (partially preserved); MPL – maxillary palp length; LPL – labial palp length; PL – pronotal length; PW – pronotal width; WL – wing pad length; FLL – foreleg length; MLL – midleg length; HLL – hind leg length; ABL – abdomen length; ABW – abdomen width; CL – cercus length (partially preserved); LFL – left foreleg; LML – left midleg; LHL – left hind leg; RFL – right foreleg; RML – right midleg; RHL – right hind leg; CE – compound eye; PR – pronotum; SM – submentum; GL – glossa; PG – paraglossa; CA – cardo; SS – stipes; LA – lacinia; LP – labial palp; MP – maxillary palp; AGR – abdominal gill remnant; CO – coxa; TR – trochanter; FE – femur; TI – tibia; TA – tarsi; CL – claw; T – tergum; ST – sternum; PP – paraproct.
Order Plecoptera Burmeister, 1839
Suborder Arctoperlaria Zwick, 1973
Kachinoperla gen. nov.
For larvae. Body robust and slightly oblate. Head wider than long; anterior ocellus present but tiny; postocular area with moderate setae; occipital row of short spinules irregularly scattered and sinuous; antennal segment near glabrous, apically with sparse short spines; predaceous mouthparts; glossae near as long as paraglossae; maxilla well-developed; cardo broad, laterally with dense short spines; stipes elongated, with rounded, glabrous outer margin; lacinia elongated, with two giant apical teeth and an inner comb of marginal spines; maxillary palpomeres elongated, apical palpomere much thinner and approximately half in length of penultimate segment; mandible with three pointed apical teeth, anterior half of inner margin with a comb of cylindrical spines; molar area unmodified; labial palp similar in length to maxillary palp, apical palpomere thin and slightly shortened, apex obliquely truncate. Pronotum near trapezoidal, with dark margins and two posteromedial pale spots, posterior margin with long spines. Wing pads banded, outline circular, dorsally and laterally covered with dense spinules; notal contour invisible; thoracic gills absent. Legs with dense long swimming hairs; tibia with two giant and several smaller apical spurs; tarsi with first two tarsomeres much shorter than third one. Abdominal segments covered and posteriorly fringed with long cylindrical spines; tergum 10 strongly projected backwards; paraprocts subtriangular, with straight inner margins and rounded posterior margins; cerci with sparse giant spines along inner and outer margins.
Kachinoperla zwicki sp. nov.
The genus name is a combination of the type locality in the Kachin State of Myanmar and the stonefly genus Perla Geoffroy, 1762. The name is feminine in gender.
By monotypy, as for the type species.
The species is named after Dr. Peter Zwick, who has made substantial contributions to the knowledge of Plecoptera.
Holotype: exuvia (No. CZT-PLE-MA13), deposited in the Insect Collection of Jiangsu University of Science and Technology (ICJUST).
Amber mine near Noije Bum Village (26°20′N, 96°36′E), Tanai Township, Myitkyina District, Kachin State, northern Myanmar. Horizon unnamed, mid-Cretaceous, Upper Albian to Lower Cenomanian (98.79±0.62 Ma).
As for the genus.
Body robust and slightly oblate (Fig.
Kachinoperla zwicki gen. et sp. nov., holotype, CZT-PLE-MA13. A Head and prothorax, dorsal view. B Head and prothorax, ventral view. C Head, ventral view. D Drawing of head, ventral view. Abbreviations: CE, compound eye; PR, pronotum; SM, submentum; GL, glossa; PG, paraglossa; CA, cardo; SS, stipes; LA, lacinia; LP, labial palp; MP, maxillary palp. Scale bars: 0.5 mm.
Kachinoperla zwicki gen. et sp. nov., holotype, CZT-PLE-MA13. A Left foreleg and left hind leg, dorsal view. B Left foreleg, ventral view. C Right foreleg and right midleg, dorsal view. D Right midleg, ventral view. E Left hind leg, ventral view. F Left midleg, dorsal view. Abbreviations: LFL, left foreleg; LML, left midleg; LHL, left hind leg; RFL, right foreleg; RML, right midleg; RHL, right hind leg; CO, coxa; TR, trochanter; FE, femur; TI, tibia; TA, tarsi; CL, claw. Scale bars: 0.5 mm.
Kachinoperla zwicki gen. et sp. nov., holotype, CZT-PLE-MA13. A Abdomen, dorsal view. B Abdominal terminal segments, dorsal view. C Abdomen, ventral view. D Abdominal terminal segments, ventral view. Abbreviations: T, tergum; ST, sternum; PP, paraproct; AGR, abdominal gill remnant. Scale bars: 0.5 mm.
BL 9.5 mm, HL 2.0 mm, HW 2.5 mm, ATL 4.0 mm (partially preserved), PL 1.2 mm, PW 2.0 mm, WL 3.0 mm, FLL 5.0 mm, MLL 6.0 mm, HLL 7.0 mm, ABL 5.0 mm, ABW 1.5 mm, CL 2.0 mm (partially preserved).
The absence of well-developed abdominal gills as either lateral or anal appendages can easily exclude Kachinoperla gen. nov. from the suborder Antarctoperlaria (
Some representatives of the extant Euholognatha, head in ventral view. A Capnia zijinshana Du & Chen, 2016 (Capniidae), adult. B C. zijinshana, larva. C Rhopalopsole vespertilio Chen & Du, 2017 (Leuctridae), adult. D R. vespertilio, larva. E Nemoura nankinensis Wu, 1926 (Nemouridae), adult. F N. nankinensis, larva. G Taenionema sp. (Taeniopterygidae), adult. H Taenionema sp., larva. I Scopura longa Uéno, 1929, larva.
Some representatives of the extant Systellognatha, head in ventral view. A Kamimuria petasus Chen, 2019c (Perlidae), adult. B K. petasus, larva. C Neofilchneria wanglanga Chen, 2019d (Perlodidae), adult. D N. wanglanga, larva. E Suwallia wolongshana Du & Chen, 2015 (Chloroperlidae), adult. F S. wolongshana, larva. G Pteronarcys sachalina Klapálek, 1908 (Pteronarcyidae), adult. H P. sachalina, larva. I Microperla retroloba (Wu, 1937) (Peltoperlidae), adult. J M. retroloba, larva. K Styloperla inae Chao, 1947 (Styloperlidae), adult. L S. inae, larva.
Larval descriptions are available for many extinct stoneflies of Systellognatha: Permian Palaeoperlidae, Tshekardoperlidae, and Tungussonympha (undetermined family in Perloidea, abbreviated as UFP below); Triassic Berekia Sinitshenkova, 1987 (UFP) and Triassoperla Lin, 1977 (UFP); Jurassic Derancheperla Sinitshenkova, 1990 (Perlodidae), Isoperlodes Sinitshenkova, 1992 (Perlodidae), Platyperlidae, Bestioperlisca Sinitshenkova, 1990 (UFP), Chloroperloides Sinitshenkova, 1985 (UFP), Perlisca Sinitshenkova, 1985 (UFP), Perlomimus Sinitshenkova, 1985 (UFP), Trianguliperla Sinitshenkova, 1985 (UFP), and Perlitodes Sinitshenkova, 1987 (UFP); and Cretaceous Dipsoperla Sinitshenkova, 1987 (Chloroperlidae), Ecdyoperla Sinitshenkova, 1998 (UFP), Savina Sinitshenkova, 1987 (UFP), and the Electroneuria (Perlidae) known from Kachin amber.
Almost all known larval fossils of Plecoptera are poorly preserved as fossil impressions and their descriptions and comparisons with other larvae or adults are restricted to the shapes and ratios of general body parts, whereas the more informative structures such as the mouthparts remain unclear (
When compared with the Jurassic taxa, Kachinoperla differs from Derancheperla by the invisibility of notal contour between wing pads (
When compared with the three Cretaceous genera known by fossil impressions, Kachinoperla can be distinguished from Dipsoperla by the head two times longer than pronotum (vs. head almost as long as pronotum), abdominal sterna complete (vs. abdominal sterna divided by a longitudinal median membrane) (
Apart from Electroneuria, all other stoneflies in Kachin amber were described based on adult morphology. Among these, all the male specimens of Perlidae were exclusively and certainly attributed to the subfamily Acroneuriinae Klapálek, 1914 by the presence of hammer on abdominal sternum 9, absence of projected hemiterga, and absence of hair brush on mesal areas of abdominal sterna (Sivec et al. 1988;
The two genera of Peltoperlidae, Zwickoperla Chen & Wang, 2020 and Borisoperla Chen & Xu, 2020, are characterized by the shortened head strongly inserted into the angulate prothorax (autapomorphy of Peltoperlidae) and share other similar characters with the extant peltoperlids (
The subequal glossae and paraglossae of Kachinoperla are reminiscent of another extinct family Petroperlidae known from Kachin amber (
Perspicuusoperlidae is another recently established extinct family from Kachin amber, which is regarded as the stem group of Euholognatha + Systellognatha (
Maximum parsimony searches and Bayesian inference were conducted to investigate the systematic position of Kachinoperla (Fig.
Phylogenetic trees based on morphological characters. A The strict consensus tree of the most parsimonious trees generated by TNT with morphological characters visualized on the cladogram using WINCLADA. The white and black circles represent homoplastic and non-homoplastic characters, respectively. Names of the taxa from Kachin amber are indicated with orange and red. The family names are in gray boxes for the extant taxa and in black boxes for the extinct taxa. The numbers above the circles are the character numbers; the numbers below are character states. B Bayesian tree. Blue circles at nodes represent posterior probabilities equal to or higher than 0.8.
Although larval characters of stoneflies can vary between different instars, the studied exuvia corresponds to the mature (last instar) larva, which has more stable and distinct characters than younger instars and is the research object of almost all larva-related taxonomic and phylogenetic studies in Plecoptera. During the comparison of stoneflies in Kachin amber, the main diagnostic characters include the size of mouthparts, the length of cercal segments, the shape of pronotum, and the body color. Abundant extant evidence (Figs
Based on the comparative discussions and phylogenetic analysis, Kachinoperla differs from any related extant and extinct taxa and is considered a basal group in Systellognatha according to its larval structures and other general external characters.
The hitherto five stonefly families known from Kachin amber of northern Myanmar, i.e., Perlidae, Petroperlidae, Peltoperlidae, Perspicuusoperlidae, and Kachinoperlidae, have exhibited both predaceous and phytophagous types of mouthparts, which suggests that the divergent evolution of feeding habits in stoneflies must have started earlier than the mid-Cretaceous. The various types of mouthparts and diverse feeding habits persist in extant Plecoptera, which allow different species to fill every conceivable major food niche in steams (
The coloration of Kachinoperla is composed of a bicolor head, a dark brown pronotum with pale spots, banded wing pads, banded femora of pale brown legs, dark brown abdominal segments, dark brown antennae, and cerci, which contrasts with the unpigmented larva (more likely to be an exuvia) of Electroneuria known also from Kachin amber. Such contrasting larval coloration might be non-functional, but it has apparently diverged from the common situation of aquatic insect larvae usually exhibiting subdued, cryptic coloration due to constraints imposed by the light environment of freshwater habitats (
The dorsal ecdysial suture of Kachinoperla consists of a Y-shaped epicranial suture, and a longitudinal thoracic suture extended from the anterior of pronotum to the posterior of metanotum, which is identical to all extant stoneflies (
The giant larval wing pads of Kachinoperla are signals of macropterous adults in the family. All other adults reported from Kachin amber are also macropterous. The reduction or complete loss of wings is quite common in extant stoneflies but it is rarely reported from fossils. Except for the genetic factor (
The well-developed swimming hairs on all larval legs of Kachinoperla as well as in Electroneuria are correlated in extant taxa with strong swimming ability to move upstream in order to avoid passive transportation by fast-flowing streams; such ability is variable among different taxonomic groups in Plecoptera (
The strong and sharp larval claws of Kachinoperla are similar to those in Electroneuria (
All data generated or analyzed during this study are included in this published article. The new material studied is preserved in the Insect Collection of Jiangsu University of Science and Technology (ICJUST, No. CZT-PLE-MA13), Jiangsu Province, China
The author declares no competing interests.
This work is funded by the Natural Science Foundation of Jiangsu Province (No. BK20201009).
The author thanks the editor and reviewers for helpful comments.
File 1
Data type: .rtf
Explanation note: List of 85 morphological characters used in the phylogenetic analyses (partially derived from
File 2
Data type: .rtf
Explanation note: Character matrix used in the phylogenetic analyses (partially adapted from