Research Article |
Corresponding author: Leonardo D. Fernández ( limnoleo@gmail.com ) Academic editor: Lorenzo Prendini
© 2022 Antonio Parra-Gómez, Leonardo D. Fernández.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
|
Research on the diversity and biogeography of Chilean millipedes represents a significant gap in knowledge. To reduce this gap we conducted a study: (1) to investigate the current state of knowledge of millipede diversity, and (2) to assess the pattern and causes underlying the latitudinal diversity gradient in Chilean millipedes. In Chile, 95 native millipede species have been recorded. However, rarefaction and extrapolation curves showed that increased sampling effort will reveal more species. An asymptotic estimate of diversity predicted that millipede diversity fluctuates between 125 and 197 species. The estimate, though, was based on a limited data set. Therefore, millipede diversity is probably higher than predicted. Chilean millipedes were categorized as micro-range endemics because they all have latitudinal ranges of less than 1,000 km (with 78% of species exhibiting latitudinal ranges of only ~222 km). Millipede species richness also exhibited a bell-shaped latitudinal diversity gradient, i.e. diversity peaks in the temperate climate of central Chile and decreases towards the arid and polar climates of northern and southern Chile. A multiple regression analysis revealed that this biogeographic pattern is shaped by environmental variables related to water availability, ambient energy inputs and climatic stability. These environmental variables are proxies for two of the five biogeographic hypotheses we tested in this study, i.e. the water-energy balance hypothesis and climatic stability hypothesis. Both hypotheses suggest that millipedes need stable, humid and warm climates to grow, survive and reproduce (niche conservatism). These climatic conditions are only found in central Chile, which is consistent with the diversity peak observed in that region.
Beta diversity, biodiversity hotspot, biogeographic hypothesis, latitudinal diversity gradient, microendemic millipedes, millipede biogeography, niche conservatism
Diplopoda is the third largest class of terrestrial arthropods after Insecta and Arachnida (
The diversity and distribution of millipedes is poorly known compared to that of other historically better studied metazoans (
Map and representative millipedes of Chile. a Chile in southwestern South America stretches from ~17°S to 56°S. b During the Pleistocene, a series of geological events (e.g. the uplift of the Andes) and climatic changes (e.g. the Last Glacial Maximum) shaped the Atacama Desert in the north (area shaded in light grey) and the Patagonian Ice Sheet in the south (area shaded in dark grey) in Chile. Since then, the Atacama Desert has favoured an arid climate at low latitudes while at the end of the Last Glacial Maximum the retreat of the Patagonian Ice Sheet set up a polar climate at high latitudes. The mid-latitudes of central Chile exhibit a temperate climate and acted as a refuge for biota during the occurrence of the historical contingencies described. c Examples of millipedes endemic to Chile. From top to bottom: Tsagonus aff. valdiviae Chamberlin, 1957; Siphonotus parguaensis Mauriès and Silva, 1971; Monenchodesmus inermis Silvestri, 1903 and Mikroporus granulatus Attems, 1898.
The Chilean north–south climatic gradient emerged during the Pleistocene as a consequence of desertification and glaciation events that modified the original warm and humid conditions of northern and southern Chile respectively (Fig.
Chile is often referred to as a biogeographic island because its political boundaries overlap with natural barriers to species dispersal. To the north Chile is bordered by the Atacama Desert, to the east by the Andes Mountains, to the west by the Pacific Ocean and to the south by the end of the South American continent (Figs
The insular condition of Chile and the historical contingencies experienced by its territory probably favoured the occurrence of a peculiar millipede fauna (Fig.
The goal of the present study is to investigate the state of knowledge and biogeography of Chilean millipedes. Specifically, we investigated the temporal variation in the number of published studies, the number of sites investigated, and the number of new species reported in Chile over the last 175 years. We also constructed rarefaction, extrapolation and asymptotic diversity curves to assess the number of species that have not yet been described in Chile. Finally, we tested five biogeographic hypotheses (Table
Ecological hypotheses tested with respect to the diversity of native millipedes in Chile and their respective predictions and predictors.
Hypothesis | Prediction | Predictors | Reference examples | |
1 | Species-energy | Diversity increases with energy inputs (including plant productivity) | UVB, NPP, NDVI, PET, AMT, MTW, MTQ, MWQ, MCQ |
|
2 | Water availability | Diversity increases with water inputs | APR, PDM, PWQ |
|
3 | Water energy-balance | Diversity increases with energy and water inputs | AET, UVB, NPP, NDVI, PET, APR, PDM, PWQ |
|
4 | Climatic stability | Diversity increases in climatically stable areas | ISO, TS, MDR, TAR, MTC, |
|
5 | Habitat heterogeneity | Diversity increases with habitat heterogeneity | ELE |
|
UVB: Ultraviolet Radiation B, NPP: Net Primary Productivity, NDVI: Normalized Difference Vegetation, PET: Potential Evapotranspiration, AMT: Annual Mean Temperature, MTW: Max Temperature of Warmest Month, MTQ: Mean Temperature Of Wettest Quarter, MWQ: Mean Temperature of Warmest Quarter, MCQ: Mean Temperature of Coldest Quarter, APR: Annual Precipitation, PDM: Precipitation of Driest Month, PWQ: Precipitation of Warmest Quarter, ISO: Isothermality, TES: Temperature Seasonality, MDR: Mean Diurnal Range, TAR: Temperature Annual Range, MTC: Min Temperature of Coldest Month, ELE: Topographic Elevation |
The database used in this study consists of 95 native species recorded in continental Chile between 1847 and 2022. We constructed this database by merging records obtained by the first author with information recently published in
We used three complementary approaches to investigate the state of knowledge of Chilean millipedes following
First, we estimated the number of published studies, the number of new sites sampled, the number of new species reported, and the cumulative number of new species reported in each decade from the 1840s onwards. We then correlated each indicator against time to investigate its trend over years using the R package spdep version 1.1–12 (
Second, we estimated a rarefaction curve to investigate whether the sampling effort invested in Chile (measured as the number of sites investigated between the 1840s and 2020s) has contributed to the completion of the checklist of Chilean millipede species. If the rarefaction curve reaches a plateau, we will conclude that the investment of additional sampling effort will not reveal a substantial number of new species in Chile. If the rarefaction curve does not reach a plateau, then we will conclude that the investment of additional sampling effort will reveal new species in Chile. We also estimated an extrapolation curve to investigate whether an increase in sampling effort will contribute to the completeness of the checklist of Chilean millipede species. If the extrapolation curve reaches a plateau, we will conclude that an increase in sampling effort will contribute to completing the checklist of Chilean millipede species. If the extrapolation curve does not reach a plateau, we will conclude that a significant increase in sampling effort is needed to complete the checklist of Chilean millipede species. We estimated the rarefaction and extrapolation curves based on the approach proposed by
Third, we constructed an asymptotic diversity profile to estimate the number of species we have yet to discover at the sites we have so far surveyed in Chile. We estimated the asymptotic diversity profile and its upper and lower 95% confidence intervals (10,000 bootstrap replicates) based on the method proposed by
We used a range interpolation approach to standardise species richness and reduce the effects of spatial sampling biases (
To investigate the latitudinal diversity gradient we divided Chile into bins of 3° latitudinal bands. We then counted the number of species recorded in each latitudinal bin and correlated species richness against latitude by fitting linear and non-linear functions in PAST version 4.09 (
Millipedes have low vagility and consist largely of micro-range endemic species, i.e. animals with geographic range (area where a particular species can be found) smaller than 1,000 km2 (
We tested a set of alternative hypotheses to investigate the causes underlying the latitudinal diversity gradient of Chilean millipedes. The null hypothesis is that millipede species richness is randomly distributed in Chile. Then, we tested five biogeographical hypotheses to explain the spatial distribution of Chilean millipede species richness (Table
To test the five biogeographical hypotheses we investigated the relationship between millipede species richness and 25 environmental variables often used as surrogates for the mechanisms proposed by these hypotheses. These environmental variables were obtained from various sources, which are detailed in Suppl. file
To investigate beta diversity or the latitudinal variation in species composition we estimated beta diversity (βSOR) as well as its underlying additive components, i.e. spatial turnover (βSIM) and nestedness (βSNE), as described by
We also conducted an analysis of similarity (ANOSIM) to investigate the variation in species composition between arid, temperate and polar climates at low, mid and high latitudes, respectively. ANOSIM compares the mean of ranked dissimilarities between groups to the mean of ranked dissimilarities within groups based on the R–statistic. An R–statistic close to “1” suggests dissimilarity between groups, an R–statistic close to “0” suggests an even distribution of high and low ranks within and between groups, while an R–statistic below “0” suggest that dissimilarities are greater within groups than between groups. The ANOSIM and significance value of the R–statistic were estimated based on 1,000 permutations in PRIMER version 6 (
We recorded a positive, significant correlation between time and the number of published studies, the number of sites sampled, the number of new species reported, and the cumulative number of new species reported in each decade (Fig.
State of knowledge of Chilean millipedes. a Number of studies published per decade. b Number of new sites sampled per decade. c Number of new species reported per decade. d Cumulative number of new species per decade. e Rarefaction curves (solid trend line), extrapolation curves (dash-dotted line) and their lower and upper 95% confidence intervals (dashed line). The point between both curves represents the number of sites where millipedes have been sampled in Chile. f Asymptotic estimate of millipede diversity in Chile (solid trend line) and its lower and upper 95% confidence intervals (dashed line).
Our analysis revealed that between 1847 and 2022 (175 years) native millipede species were described or reported in 30 studies. The number of published studies exhibits two peaks over time, i.e. one in the 1970s and another in the 2010s with eight and seven published studies, respectively. The remaining decades exhibit between one and three published studies. While we recorded an increase in the number of studies of Chilean millipedes over time, we also noted extended periods without published records. These include the periods between 1848 and 1897 (49 years); 1906 and 1915 (nine years) and more recently between the 1989 and 2011 (22 years) (Fig.
A review of the 30 published studies on Chilean millipedes revealed that researchers have explored the diversity of these invertebrates at 140 unique sites. Eleven studies (37%) are based on a single study site, four (13%) on three sites, three (10%) on two sites, three (10%) on eight sites, two (7%) on 13 sites, two (7%) on six sites, two (7%) on five sites, one (3%) on 19 sites, one (3%) on 11 sites and one (3%) on nine sites. The number of new sites sampled exhibits a peak in the 1970s with 30 new sites sampled. The 1900s, 1950s and 2010s also stand out with 22, 20 and 21 new sites sampled. The number of new sites sampled during the remaining decades ranges between 1 and 11 sites. Overall our analysis suggests that, even though there are extended periods without published records, the number of new sites investigated has increased over time, particularly since the 1900s (Fig.
The number of new millipede species also increased significantly over time, although the correlation coefficient is low. This is because the number of new species reported varies significantly from decade to decade, with values ranging from one to 17 species. The highest number of new species was recorded in the 1950s (17 species), and the lowest number of species was recorded in the 1910s and 1940s (1 species each time) (Fig.
Although the number of new species reported varies significantly between decades, the cumulative number of new species has increased exponentially over time. Between the 1840s and 2020s the number of native species known for Chile has increased from three to 95 (including described species and species that have yet to be formally described; see the species list provided in Suppl. file
Rarefaction and extrapolation curves confirmed the above result. The rarefaction curve did not reach a plateau suggesting that the sampling effort has been insufficient to record a substantial number of the species inhabiting Chile. So, future studies will add new species to the checklist of Chilean millipedes. The extrapolation curve also did not reach a plateau, suggesting that doubling the sampling effort would also not contribute to recording a significant fraction of the millipede species present in Chile. Therefore, we need to invest a greater sampling effort over time to complete the checklist of Chilean millipedes (Fig.
The diversity estimate suggests that altogether, the sites surveyed between the 1840s and 2020s harbour at least 158 native species (considering 95% lower and upper confidence intervals of 125 and 197 species). Thus, our analysis suggests that we have missed at least one-third of the millipede species that actually inhabit the sites surveyed between the 1840s and 2020s. Therefore a significant increase in sampling effort could reveal up to 102 additional species (Fig.
Millipedes exhibit a bell-shaped (unimodal) latitudinal diversity gradient in Chile. Thus, species richness exhibits a peak in the mid-latitudes (central Chile) and then decreases towards low (northern Chile) and high (southern Chile) latitudes (Fig.
Biogeography of Chilean millipedes. a Bell-shaped latitudinal diversity gradient. The second-degree polynomial function (segmented line) reveals that millipede diversity peaks in central Chile and then decreases significantly towards northern and southern Chile. b Latitudinal range size of millipede species. All species were categorized as micro-range endemics because they all have latitudinal ranges of less than 1,000 km (with 78% of species exhibiting latitudinal ranges of only ~222 km).
Analysis of the geographic ranges of millipedes revealed that their latitudinal ranges can be categorised as micro-range endemics as all species exhibit latitudinal ranges of less than 1,000 km. Of the 95 native species included in our study, 74 (78%) exhibit latitudinal ranges of ~220 km, 17 (18%) have ranges of ~550 km and 4 (4%) have ranges of ~880 km (Fig.
The bell-shaped latitudinal diversity gradient of Chilean millipedes is positively and significantly correlated with a subset of five environmental variables, including Ultraviolet Radiation B (UVB), Normalised Difference Vegetation (NDVI), Annual Precipitation (APR), Mean Diurnal Range (MDR) and Isothermality (ISO) (BioEnv, R = 0.787, p = 0.01). UVB and NDVI are proxies for energy, APR is a proxy for water availability, while MDR and ISO are proxies for climatic stability. The observed correlation between millipede diversity and these proxies lends support to the water–energy balance and the climatic stability hypotheses. The water-energy balance states that species richness is high at sites that exhibit high energy and water inputs during the year (
Millipedes have a high beta diversity in Chile (βSOR = 0.94; Fig.
Beta diversity or latitudinal variation of Chilean millipede species composition. The curves in the kernel density plot show the distribution of observed values for beta diversity (βSOR, solid curve) and its two additive components, spatial turnover (βSIM, segmented curve) and nestedness (βSNE, dotted curve). According to this analysis, millipede beta diversity is mainly modulated by species turnover between latitudinal bands. Therefore, species composition changes latitudinally following the north-south climatic gradient that characterizes Chile.
Millipedes are a poorly known group in Chile and represent a significant gap in knowledge for myriapodology worldwide (
Our analyses revealed that sampling effort and the number of published studies have increased, albeit only modestly, over the last 175 years. Both indicators are low between the mid-19th and mid-20th centuries, probably because during that period it was very difficult to obtain samples from Chile. Researchers from Europe and North America travelled months to get to Chile and usually the samples did not arrive in good condition back to the laboratory (
The sampling effort and the number of publications increased notably during the second half of the 20th century thanks to the contributions of the Chilean myriapodologist Francisco Silva. This researcher remained active for 13 years until his premature death in the 1990s (
In Chile there are 95 native species of millipedes (
Although we used a robust method to estimate millipede diversity (see Chao et al. 2015), we believe that we have underestimated the diversity of Chilean millipedes. Our estimate is based on diversity data collected at 140 sites, which represents a small fraction of the area included within Chile’s extensive latitudinal and altitudinal gradients. Each of these gradients contains thousands of sites where millipede diversity has never been investigated. In turn, each of these sites represents a myriad of microhabitats with local environmental conditions that could contain a substantial number of native species still unknown to Chile and science (
After accounting for spatial bias in sampling effort we observed that millipede species richness follows a bell-shaped latitudinal diversity gradient, i.e. diversity peaks at mid-latitudes and decreases monotonically towards low and high latitudes. The observed latitudinal diversity gradient is not unique to these invertebrates. Many macro- (e.g.
Of the 95 species included in our study, 92 are endemic and three are native to Chile (
Most micro-range endemic species accumulate in central Chile, contributing to the diversity peak we observed in mid-latitudes. This area is known as a hotspot of diversity and endemism (
Millipede diversity was positively correlated with a subset of climatic variables related to climatic seasonality, water availability and ambient energy inputs. Thus, millipedes are more diverse in latitudinal bands that have a mesophilic or temperate (warm and humid) climate for most of the year. This result supports two of the five biogeographical hypotheses tested in this study: the climatic stability hypothesis and the water-energy balance hypothesis.
Chile exhibits a mesophilic or temperate climate (humid and warm) in the mid-latitudes (
Our results are consistent with the conclusion of other authors.
The relationship between millipedes and water availability is because these invertebrates are vulnerable to desiccation. Their cuticle generally lacks a waterproof layer, their gas exchange system is not closed, and they lose a considerable amount of water through the mouth, in defecation, and during reproduction (
Possibly the need for warm, humid climates is a phylogenetically conserved trait in millipedes (
Beta diversity or spatial variation in millipede species composition varies from north to south based on strong species turnover compared to nestedness. Species turnover or species replacement is particularly strong and significant between the arid climate of low latitudes, the temperate climate of mid-latitudes, and the polar climate of high latitudes. Species turnover is often more important than nestedness when species distributions occur in response to an environmental gradient or when there are spatial and historical constraints (Baselga 2012;
There are 95 native millipede species in Chile (considering described species, species that have not yet been formally described and subspecies that will ultimately be promoted to species), although we estimate that the diversity is between 125 and 197 species. Our estimate is based on limited data and so, the diversity of Chilean millipedes could be higher than expected. In line with this conclusion, rarefaction and extrapolation curves suggest that the sampling effort invested in the last 175 years has been insufficient to record a substantial number of millipede species inhabiting Chile. To reverse this situation we need to significantly increase sampling effort across the extensive latitudinal and altitudinal gradients that characterize Chile.
The species richness of Chilean millipedes is distributed from north to south following a bell-shaped latitudinal diversity gradient, i.e. diversity peaks at mid-latitudes and decreases towards low and high latitudes. The diversity peak is caused by the accumulation of species with narrow geographic ranges in the mid-latitudes, a zone recognized as a hotspot of biodiversity and endemism for multi- and unicellular organisms. Species composition changes significantly between the arid climate of low latitudes, the temperate climate of mid-latitudes and the polar climate of high latitudes. Consistently, the variables that best predict the pattern and causes underlying the latitudinal diversity gradient of Chilean millipedes are climate stability, water availability and ambient energy inputs. Thus, Chilean millipedes are more diverse at sites that exhibit temperate (humid and warm) climates throughout much of the year. This result suggests that the biogeography of Chilean millipedes is predicted by the mechanisms proposed by two biogeographic hypotheses, i.e., climatic stability and water-energy balance. Possibly, water availability, ambient energy inputs, and climatic stability also predict broad-scale diversity patterns in millipedes from other regions of the planet.
The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
APG and LDF conceived the idea. APG collected the data and LDF conducted the statistical and biogeographical analyses. Both authors wrote the manuscript and gave final approval for publication.
This manuscript was substantially improved by comments and suggestions provided by Sergei Golovatch, Paul Marek and an anonymous reviewer. Special thanks to Jackson Means who proofread the manuscript. APG thanks his parents for supporting his studies in BSc Biology. LDF is funded by the project Fondecyt Regular N° 1220605 awarded by the Agencia Nacional de Investigación y Desarrollo (ANID), Chile. Both authors thank Jorge Pérez, Francisco Urra, Juan Campodonico, José Contreras and Edgardo Flores for providing biological material for this study.
Names and occurrences of Chilean millipede species
Data type: .csv
Explanation note: Database of the species used in this study.
Obtaining the environmental variables used in this study
Data type: .docx
Explanation note: We provide the sources and methods used to estimate the environmental variables used in the present study.