Research Article |
Corresponding author: Andrijana Andrić ( andrijana.andric@biosense.rs ) Academic editor: Bradley Sinclair
© 2021 Ante Vujić, Tamara Tot, Andrijana Andrić, Jelena Ačanski, Ljiljana Šašić Zorić, Celeste Pérez-Bañón, Andrea Aracil, Sanja Veselić, Maja Arok, Ximo Mengual, André van Eck, Santos Rojo, Snežana Radenković.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Vujić A, Tot T, Andrić A, Ačanski J, Šašić Zorić L, Pérez-Bañón C, Aracil A, Veselić S, Arok M, Mengual X, van Eck A, Rojo S, Radenković S (2021) Review of the Merodon natans group with description of a new species, a key to the adults of known species of the natans lineage and first descriptions of some preimaginal stages. Arthropod Systematics & Phylogeny 79: 343-378. https://doi.org/10.3897/asp.79.e65861
|
Abstract
Merodon natans group (Diptera, Syrphidae) taxa are reviewed using an integrative taxonomic approach combining morphological, morphometric and molecular techniques. The approach substantiates recognition of the three species: M. calcaratus (Fabricius, 1794), M. natans (Fabricius, 1794) and M. pulveris Vujić & Radenković in
distribution, flower flies, geometric morphometrics, immature stages, integrative taxonomy, Merodon makrisi sp. nov., mtDNA COI gene, nuclear 28S rRNA gene
The phytophagous hoverfly genus Merodon Meigen, 1803 (Diptera, Syrphidae) contains 234 species distributed in the Palaearctic and Afrotropical regions, and introduced into North America and New Zealand (
The Merodon fauna of the Balkan Peninsula, Aegean Islands, Turkey and the Iberian Peninsula are the most comprehensively explored (
Based on the mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase I (COI) and nuclear 28S rRNA gene sequences of Merodon species from Europe and Turkey, three well supported clades within the genus Merodon were established (
The Merodon natans lineage contains the M. natans group and M. segetum (Fabricius, 1794) as an individual taxon. The Merodon natans group contains medium sized species with distinct pollinose ornamentation, vittae and fasciae on the scutum, and terga 2–4 with broad pollinose fasciae. This group includes three already known species, M. calcaratus (Fabricius, 1794), M. natans (Fabricius, 1794) and M. pulveris Vujić & Radenković in
The aims of the present study are: 1) to review specimens of this group deposited in several entomological institutions and private collections; 2) to define and describe a new taxon of the Merodon natans species group, with geographical distribution map of all species presented; 3) to infer the species diversity within this species group using molecular and geometric morphometric data; 4) to present the first data about the preimaginal morphology of some species of this group; and 5) to discuss biological data about the host plants of the M. natans group.
Institutional acronyms. The present study was based on examination of specimens belonging to the Merodon natans group deposited in the following entomological collections (abbreviations mentioned in the material citations are given in bold): Axel Ssymank collection, Bonn, Germany (AS coll.); André van Eck collection, Tilburg, The Netherlands (AvE coll.); Dieter Doczkal collection, München, Germany (DD coll.); Daniele Sommaggio collection, Bologna, Italy (DS coll.); Miroslav Barták collection, Prague, Czech Republic (MB coll.); Michael de Courcy Williams collection, Alexandroupoli, Greece (MCW coll.); Jeroen van Steenis collection, Amersfoort, The Netherlands (JvS coll.); Natural History Museum, London, United Kingdom (
Examined material. During our detailed investigation of the Merodon natans group in the collections mentioned above, we examined more than one thousand specimens (n=549 M. natans; n=426 M. pulveris; n=89 M. makrisi Vujić, Radenković & Tot sp. nov.; n=60 M. calcaratus) collected over a 158 year period (1862–2020) from Algeria, Bulgaria, Croatia, Cyprus, France, Greece, Israel, Italy, Kenya, Libya, Montenegro, Morocco, North Macedonia, Portugal, Serbia, Somalia, Spain, Tunis and Turkey. Most of the captured adult specimens were collected using entomological nets, except for some specimens from Miroslav Barták’s collection and
During three different field investigations of the localities where large populations of adult Merodon were previously recorded, two Merodon pupae were found (on Cyprus in February and in Serbia in September) and a larva (on Lesvos in April), all in the bulbs of Prospero autumnale (L.) Speta (Asparagaceae). Pupae were collected with the bulbs and reared at an ambient temperature until adults emerged. The larva was kept frozen (-20 °C) for several days and preserved in 70% ethanol. The studied material of the immature stages has been deposited in the collection of
Type material. All types of the known species of Merodon natans group were examined by Ante Vujić, except for the type material of M. natans because the type specimen is destroyed (
Morphological study of adults. External morphological features of adults and characters of the male terminalia were observed using a Nikon SMZ 745T (Nikon Corporation, Tokyo, Japan) stereomicroscope. For studying the male terminalia structure, specimens were first relaxed in a humidity chamber and then their terminalia were extracted with a hook-tipped entomological pin. The terminalia were cleaned by boiling in a 10% solution of potassium hydroxide (KOH) for 3–5 minutes. This was followed by brief immersion in glacial acetic acid (CH3COOH) to neutralize the KOH, and then by immersion in ethanol (C2H5OH) to remove the acid. Terminalia were examined and dissected in several drops of glycerin under stereomicroscope and finally, were stored in plastic microvials and pinned with the source specimens. Measurements of specimen size were made with the same stereoscope using an eyepiece graticule. Body length was measured from the frontal prominence, excluding the antenna to the tip of the abdomen. The length of the basoflagellomere was measured from its base to the apex (Fig.
Morphological study of the immature stages. Puparia were cleaned before morphological analysis. To do so, they were immersed in water for several hours. Soil and debris were removed from the surface using pins and brushes, and puparia were placed in an ultrasonic cleaner for five minutes, until adherent material had fallen off the integument. The head skeleton was removed from the antero-ventral margin of the puparium using entomological pins, then soaked in 10% potassium hydroxide (KOH) and heated for 15 minutes in order to remove the remaining tissue. It was then soaked in acetic acid to neutralize the KOH, followed by 70% ethanol to eliminate the acid, for a few minutes each. The skeleton was then preserved and examined in glycerin. The larva was frozen (-20°C) and preserved in 70% ethanol; no special preparation for the analysis was conducted.
Morphological studies on the puparium were conducted using a Hitachi SEM (Scanning Electron Microscope) S3000N (Hitachi Ltd, Tokyo, Japan) at 20 kV at variable-pressure (or low vacuum) mode and a Leica DFC 320 digital camera attached to a Leica MZ16 stereomicroscope (Leica Microsystems, Wetzlar, Germany). A Leica M205C stereomicroscope (with Leica DFC450 camera) (Leica Microsystems, Wetzlar, Germany) was used for the examination of the larva and for a general view of the puparium. Olympus SZX16 (with Olympus U-TVO.5XC-3 camera) (Olympus Corporation, Tokyo, Japan) and Nikon SMZ 745T (with Nikon Coolpix D7100 digital camera) (Nikon Corporation, Tokyo, Japan) stereomicroscopes were used for the examination of the head skeletons. Puparium dimensions were measured using an eyepiece micrometer attached to the stereomicroscope. Maximum puparial length, including the posterior respiratory process (prp), and maximum puparial width were recorded.
Morphological terminology. The adult morphological terminology used in descriptions and drawings follows
The general terminology for hoverfly immature stages follows
Abbreviations. Abbreviations for antenna are shown in Fig.
Drawings and photos. Drawings were made with a FSA 25 PE drawing tube attached to Leica MZ16 stereomicroscope. Leica DFC 320 digital camera (Leica Microsystems, Wetzlar, Germany) attached to Leica MZ16 stereomicroscope was used to take photos for Figures
Distribution map. The geographical distribution map of all species of the Merodon natans group was produced with the aid of DIVA-GIS version 7.5 (
Antenna. A, B, J Merodon natans C, D, K M. pulveris E, F, I M. makrisi Vujić, Radenković & Tot sp. nov. G, H M. calcaratus; A, C, E, G male B, D, F, H–K female; A–H lateral view I–K dorsal view; A Greece (Olimp) B Greece (Achaia) C, D Turkey E, F, I Cyprus G, H Spain J Greece (Alexandroupoli) K Turkey. Scale bar: 0.2 mm.
Geometric morphometric analysis of wing shape, based on measurements of the venation, was conducted using 285 specimens (209 specimens from
Three separate geometric morphometric analyses were conducted. Two analyses for species level identification were carried out separately on males and females due to sexual dimorphism (
The geometric morphometric analyses were based on right wings which were dissected using micro-scissors under Nikon SMZ 745T stereomicroscope and mounted on a microscopic slide using Hoyer’s medium. Each wing was labeled with a unique code for the
Eleven homologous landmarks, evenly distributed across the wing, were digitized using TpsDig 2.05 (
To explore wing-shape variation among specimens without a priori defined groups, a principal component analysis (PCA) was carried out. Next, the discriminant function analysis (DA) and canonical variate analysis (CVA) were employed to analyse the shape differences among species and populations. Phenetic relationships among the species and populations were characterised using an unweighted pair group method with arithmetic mean cluster analysis (UPGMA) based on squared Mahalanobis distances computed from the discriminant function analysis. Superimposed outline drawings were produced using MorphoJ version 2.0 (
Genomic DNA of 42 adult hoverfly specimens was obtained for the present study. For specimens processed at
For sequences obtained at
The COI and 28S rRNA gene sequences were edited for base-calling errors using BioEdit 7.0.9.0. (
To test pairwise correlations between morphometric, genetic, and geographical distances among species, simple two-tailed Mantel tests were performed (
Species belonging to the Merodon natans lineage, including M. segetum, share the following characters: posterior side of mesocoxa with less than 10 pile; pile on anterior anepisternum reduced; anterior lobe of surstylus in its inner side well developed, oval, rounded, pilose, without curved distal prolongation (Figs
The Merodon natans species group (Fig.
Syrphus calcaratus Fabricius, 1794: 301.
Merodon calcaratus is a medium sized (8–11 mm) black species. It can be easily distinguished from other members of the M. natans group by its shorter antenna; curved dorsal margin of basoflagellomere; small fossette near apex of basoflagellomere (Fig.
Holotype
: NORTH WEST AFRICA: 1 ♂, original labels: “Zywan Africae”, “E. calcaratus”, “type” [red label] in J.C. Fabricius collection (
MALE. Head: Antenna: short, dark brown to blackish; basoflagellomere about 1.75 times as long as wide with curved dorsal margin; small fossette positioned near apex of basoflagellomere. Face: black, white pollinose; covered with long white pile as long as pedicel; ventral part of face and anteroventral part of gena black, shiny; frontal triangle black, white pollinose, covered with dense, long white pile as long as pedicel; eyes holoptic, covered with white pile as long as scape; vertical triangle isosceles black, shiny, except for anterior part to anterior ocellus and posterior part to posterior ocelli white pollinose; vertical triangle covered with intermixed long white and black pile as long as pile on frontal triangle; ocellar triangle equilateral; occiput blackish white pollinose covered with white pile as long as pile on vertical triangle. Thorax: Scutum black, with less developed white pollinose vittae; covered with yellow erect pile as long as pile on occiput, in some specimens black pile present on area between transverse suture and scutellum; area above wing base with short black bristles; scutellum black covered with long yellowish pile as long as pile on scutum; pleura black, white pollinose; dorsal part of anterior anepisternum, posterior anepisternum, anterior anepimeron, dorsomedial part of anepimeron with long, dense white pile as long as pile on scutum; long white pile on katepisternum broadly separated with bare area between; proepimeron and katatergum with some white pile. Legs: femora black, yellow only at apex; metafemur narrowed (Fig.
Merodon calcaratus is characterized by its easily recognizable narrow and long posterior surstyle lobe which however, is highly variable in its shape amongst specimens from different geographical populations: very narrow in width in specimens from Morocco (Fig.
The preferred environment of the species is semi-arid, sandy calcareous grasslands with scattered Pinus pinea L. in Portugal (
Merodon aff. natans
in
CYPRUS: Limassol, Platres, Trooditissa Picnic Site, 4 Oct. 2017, X. Mengual leg.
Holotype
: 1 ♂, pinned, with genitalia in a separate microvial with glycerine. Left metaleg glued to the locality label. Original labels: “Cyprus: Limassol, Platres, / Trooditissa Picnic Site, 1340m., / 34.914736°N 32.842261°E, / 4 Oct. 2017. X. Mengual leg.”, “DNA voucher specimen /
Merodon makrisi Vujić, Radenković & Tot sp. nov. A male in Cyprus, photo: C. Makris, 14 Nov. 2016 B female in Cyprus, photo: C. Makris, 24 Oct. 2013 C typical habitat in Cyprus where M. makrisi Vujić, Radenković & Tot sp. nov. can be collected. Bulbs of Prospero autumnale were collected in the patch in the front, from which one male specimen was reared. Photo: A. van Eck, 7 Feb. 2016.
Morphological features such as a large fossette (Fig.
Merodon makrisi sp. nov. is a medium sized species (9–13 mm). Morphological features such as a longer basoflagellomere (Fig.
Male (Fig.
The population of Merodon makrisi sp. nov. in Cyprus is characterized by some stable morphological characters: eyes with dense white pile; tergum 2 without anterolateral reddish maculae; lateral margin of abdomen blackish; fasciae on terga smaller and narrower than in mainland specimens of M. makrisi sp. nov. and Autumn generation specimens of M. pulveris, while in specimens from mainland (Israel) these features are variable. The population of M. makrisi nov. from Cyprus shares very similar characteristics of its fasciae with the spring generation of M. pulveris: their smaller and narrower fasciae on terga, medially pointed at least on tergum 3, not reaching the lateral margin of terga are present also in the spring generation of M. pulveris.
The specific epithet is derived from the personal name Makris (a noun in genitive case). The species is dedicated to Christodoulos Makris, who collected the main part of the type series of the new species. He is an excellent observer, ecologist, photographer and author of Cyprus wildlife, insects and plants.
Merodon makrisi sp. nov. is found in Cyprus, Israel and Somalia (Fig.
In Cyprus, this species is commonly found on or near calcareous soils in rocky habitats with bulbs and orchids, around patches with open vegetation (Fig.
Merodon makrisi Vujić, Radenković & Tot sp. nov. male genitalia, Cyprus. A epandrium B left surstyle C, E hypandrium D aedeagus and associated structures; A, C, D lateral view B, E ventral view. Abbreviations: a - anterior surstyle lobe, aa - aedeagal apodeme, ae - aedeagus, c - cercus, ea - ejaculatory apodeme, la - lateral sclerite of aedeagus, n - notch on theca to which is attached the aedeagal apodeme, p - posterior surstyle lobe, v - triangular prominence on ventral margin of posterior surstyle lobe. Scale bar: 0.2 mm.
Syrphus natans Fabricius, 1794: 283.
Syrphus annulatus Fabricius, 1794: 296. syn. nov.
Syrphus melancholicus Fabricius, 1794: 302.
Merodon natans is a medium sized species (8–12 mm), which can be easily distinguished from M. calcaratus by its longer antenna (Fig.
Syrphus natans Fabricius: Type locality: Italy. Original Puparium description was based on an unspecified number of specimens. One appropriately labelled type was located in J.C. Fabricius collection (
Male (Fig.
The posterior surstyle lobe in males of M. natans varies in shape, as in the case of M. calcaratus, but is less distinct. In the Montenegro (Boka Kotorska) population of M. natans and in a single specimen from Spain, the posterior surstyle lobe is narrower (Fig.
Merodon natans occurs in most countries of southern Europe (Spain, Italy, Croatia, Serbia, Bulgaria, North Macedonia, Montenegro, Greece) and part of western Europe (France) (Fig.
Preferred environments are forests with open ground; herb-rich open areas in thermophilous Quercus forest and phrygana with Cistus scrub; also in orchards in southern Europe (
This study revealed that records from Portugal (
Merodon pulveris
Vujić & Radenković in
Merodon pulveris is a medium sized species (11–12 mm). It can be separated from M. calcaratus by its longer antenna (Fig.
We studied the type material published in
Merodon pulveris inhabits the Anatolian Peninsula, the eastern Mediterranean islands (Lesvos, Samos, Rhodes) and Cyprus, but is absent from southern and western Europe as opposed to M. natans (Fig.
Preferred environments (Fig.
1. | Area of short black pile present on anterobasal ~1/4 of profemur, ~1/5 of mesofemur and ~1/6–1/7 of metafemur (Fig. |
M. segetum |
– | Pro-, meso- and metafemora anterobasally without area of short black pile (Fig. |
2 (M. natans group) |
2. | Antenna shorter, less than 2 times (approx. 1.75) longer than broad (Fig. |
M. calcaratus |
– | Antenna longer, at least 2 times longer than broad (Fig. |
3 |
3. | Eyes holoptic (males) | 4 |
– | Eyes dichoptic (females) | 6 |
4. | Male genitalia: ventral margin of posterior surstyle lobe without visible triangular prominence in lateral view (Fig. |
M. natans |
– | Male genitalia: ventral margin of posterior surstyle lobe with clearly visible triangular prominence in lateral view (Fig. |
5 |
5. | Fosette large, extending from base of arista to apex of basoflagellomere (Fig. |
M. makrisi Vujić, Radenković & Tot sp. nov. |
– | Fosette smaller, never extending from base of arista to apex of basoflagellomere (Fig. |
M. pulveris |
6. | Position of fossette close to base of arista (Fig. |
M. makrisi sp. nov. |
– | Fossette position medially between base of arista and apex of basofagellomere (Fig. |
7 |
7. | Tarsomeres of proleg covered with yellow pile, with some intermixed black pile. Distribution: Southern Europe (Spain, Italy, Croatia, Serbia, Bulgaria, North Macedonia, Montenegro, Greece) and parts of western Europe (France) | M. natans |
– | Tarsomeres of proleg with yellow pile, in some specimens only fifth tarsomere with sparse black pile. Distribution: Anatolian Peninsula, the eastern Mediterranean islands (Lesvos, Samos, Rhodes) and Cyprus | M. pulveris |
Most morphological characters of the puparia of M. makrisi sp. nov. and M. natans appear to be very similar, however the single specimen of M. natans is damaged and morphological analysis using electron microscopy could not be performed. Therefore, although the following Puparium description refers to both species, most of the characters have been described for M. makrisi sp. nov., but the features that seem to be different between them have been emphasized.
Puparium description
(Merodon makrisi sp. nov. n=2; M. natans n=1): Dimensions and shape (Fig.
Light micrographs of Merodon makrisi Vujić, Radenković & Tot sp. nov. puparium. A puparium in dorsal view B head skeleton in lateral view. Abbreviations: c – cibarium, db - dorsal bridge, dc – dorsal cornu, is – intermediate sclerite, m – mandibles, mo – mortar, p – pestle, vc – ventral cornu, vp – vertical plate. Scale bars: 2 mm (A); 200 μm (B).
SEM micrographs of Merodon makrisi Vujić, Radenković & Tot sp. nov. puparium. A pupal spiracle in dorsal view B pupal spiracle in ventral view C anterior spiracle D posterior respiratory process (prp) in dorsal view E anal segment F prp showing the spiracular plate. Abbreviations: cs – central scar, is – inter-spiracular setae, lp – lappets, prp – posterior respiratory process, so – spiracular opening, tu – tubercle. Scale bars: 200 μm (A, B); 100 μm (C); 500 μm (D, E, F).
Material examined: Merodon makrisi sp. nov.: CYPRUS, Episkopi, Kourion; 34.6699°N, 32.8754°E; A. van Eck leg.; 2 puparia (1 whole, 1 in parts) in bulbs of Prospero autumnale, 7 Feb. 2016, reared, 1 male emerged 21 Oct. 2016;
Larva dimensions and shape
: Length: 9 mm, width: 3 mm; sub-cylindrical; roundly arched dorsally and slightly flattened ventrally; anterior end truncated, inclined ventrally; uniformly yellowish to light brown in colour; rough integument with segmentation as transverse wrinkles, anterior segments corrugated with conspicuous folds; integumental vestiture well-developed, with short slightly pointed and sclerotized yellowish-brown spicules; segmental sensilla all conspicuous, consisting of wider basal papilla bearing very long needle-like terminal setae (Fig.
Light micrographs of Merodon pulveris larva. A mandibles B head C primordia of pupal spiracles D posterior part of the abdomen in dorsal view E posterior part of the abdomen in ventral view. Abbreviations: am – antenno-maxillary organs, as – anterior spiracle, eat – external accessory teeth, iat – internal accessory teeth, lp – lappets, mh – mouthhooks, pps – primordia of pupal spiracles, prp – posterior respiratory process. Scale bars: 200 μm (A, B); 1 mm (C, D); 500 μm (E).
Material examined. GREECE, Lesvos Island, Loutra; 39.0510°N, 26.5312°E; Apr. 2018; A. Vujić leg.; 1 (L3 instar) larva in bulb of Prospero autumnale (Lp in
The concatenated 5’-end and 3’-end COI gene sequence matrix contains 61 sequences of 1,358 bp length. The total number of the variable positions is 429, while 331 are parsimony informative. As a result of MP analysis, we inferred a strict consensus tree (length=1,242, consistency index=0.45, retention index=0.78) of four equally parsimonious trees (see Supplementary file
Maximum likelihood tree of Merodon natans species group based on COI gene sequence analysis. Bootstrap values ≥ 50 are presented near nodes. Coloured sections indicate different Merodon lineages (yellow – aureus lineage, light green – desuturinus lineage, dark green – albifrons lineage, blue – avidus lineage, purple – natans lineage).
Genetic distances based on concatenated 5’-end and 3’-end COI gene sequences between species pairs within the M. natans species group are in the range from 5.1% between M. natans and M. pulveris to 6.4% between M. pulveris and M. makrisi sp. nov. (Table
Genetic distances* based on concatenated 5'-end and 3'-end COI gene sequences between species within the M. natans species group.
Species | M. natans | M. pulveris | M. calcaratus |
M. natans | |||
M. pulveris | 5.1 | ||
M. calcaratus | 5.3 | 5.9 | |
M. makrisi sp. nov. | 5.4 | 6.4 | 5.6 |
*Average uncorrected p distances expressed as percentages. |
The combined COI+28S rRNA gene sequence matrix contains 48 sequences. The total length is 1,957 bp and there are 515 variable positions from which 377 are parsimony informative. Merodon makrisi sp. nov. is present with only one specimen due to lower sequencing success of 28S rRNA gene compared to COI gene. MP analysis resulted in a strict consensus tree (length=1,358 bp, consistency index=0.48, retention index=0.76) of two equally parsimonious trees and had similar topology as ML tree (Fig.
Maximum likelihood tree of Merodon natans species group based on combined COI+28S rRNA gene sequence analysis. Bootstrap values ≥ 50 are presented near nodes. Coloured sections indicate different Merodon lineages (yellow - aureus lineage, light green - desuturinus lineage, dark green - albifrons lineage, blue - avidus lineage, purple - natans lineage).
Wing shape variation among specimens was quantified using PCA, which produced 18 principal components (PCs) in total within both males and females. First two principal components (PCs) described 35% of wing-shape variation among male specimens and 36% among female specimens. In the space defined by the first two PCs groupings of conspecific specimens is clearly noticeable within both males and females (Fig.
Discriminant analysis provided evidence for highly significant wing shape differences among all species pairs (P < 0.01; males: M. natans - M. pulveris F18, 129=41.67; M. natans - M. calcaratus F18, 129=13.43; M. calcaratus - M. pulveris F18, 129=18.57. Females: M. natans - M. pulveris F18, 116=30.43; M. natans - M. calcaratus F18, 116=40.53; M. calcaratus - M. pulveris F18, 116=27.86). Additionally, DA with cross-validation based on wing shape showed correct species assignment for 97.32% male specimens and 98.53% for female specimens. Among the 149 male specimens, four were misclassified, one M. pulveris and two M. calcaratus as M. natans, and one specimen of M. natans as M. pulveris. Within 136 female specimens, only two specimens of M. natans were misclassified as M. pulveris. All female specimens of M. pulveris and M. calcaratus were correctly classified.
CVA conducted on wing shape parameters gave two highly significant canonical axes within both males and females (Males: CV1: Wilks’=0.0520, χ2=406.5518, p < .01; CV2: Wilks’=0.3607, χ2=140.2089, p < .01; Females: CV1: Wilks’=0.0293, χ2=439.3760, p < .01; CV2: Wilks’=0.2190, χ2=189.0509, p < .01).
Within males, CV1 with 77% of wing shape variation clearly differentiates M. pulveris from M. natans and M. calcaratus, while CV2 with 23% of shape variation clearly separated M. calcaratus from M. natans and M. pulveris (Fig.
Wing shape differences among males of Merodon natans, M. pulveris and M. calcaratus. A Scatter plot of individual scores of CV1 and CV2 B, C, D Superimposed outline drawings showing differences in average wing shape for each species pair. Differences between the species were exaggerated 3-fold to make them more visible E UPGMA phenogram constructed using squared Mahalanobis distances of wing shape.
Wing shape differences among females of Merodon natans, M. pulveris and M. calcaratus. A Scatter plot of individual scores of CV1 and CV2 B, C, D Superimposed outline drawings showing differences in average wing shape for each species pair. Differences between the species were exaggerated 3-fold to make them more visible E UPGMA phenogram constructed using squared Mahalanobis distances of wing shape.
Phenogram based on squared Mahalanobis distances showed different phenetic relationships within males and females (Figs
Pairwise differences in average wing shape were visualised using superimposed outline drawings which allows recognition of wing regions that are contributing to the species discrimination (Figs
Wing shape variation among populations was measured using discriminant and canonical variate analysis. DA showed correct classification for 81.85% of the specimens. Out of 270 specimens, 49 are misclassified, 46 into other conspecific populations, and only three as other species. Based on the UPGMA cluster analysis constructed with the Mahalanobis square distances, M. natans populations were the closest to each other, forming a cluster. Within this cluster, the population from Greece, Crete had the most distinct wing shape (Fig.
CVA produced eight significant CV axes, from which the first two were describing 72% of total shape variation (Fig.
Wing shape differences among populations of Merodon natans, M. pulveris and M. calcaratus. A Scatter plot of individual scores of CV1 and CV2 B UPGMA phenogram constructed using squared Mahalanobis distances of wing shape C Map of Mediterranean basin showing the distribution of populations used in the analysis.
Simple two-tailed Mantel tests revealed that geographical distance was not significantly correlated with wing shape differentiation nor with genetic differentiation among M. natans, M. pulveris and M. calcaratus (wing – geography: p=0.63474, r=0.76691; genetic- geography: p=0.14519, r=0.97433).
The Merodon natans lineage as an independent evolutionary clade was first established by
The integrative taxonomy approach using multiple data sources implemented in this study supports species delimitation based on morphological differences within the M. natans group. Thus, it has proved useful in taxonomy of the group, as it has been in many previous studies on the genus Merodon (e.g.,
The four closely related species of the Merodon natans group have diagnostic morphological differences. Although M. calcaratus has exhibited high intraspecific variability, this species has diagnostic characters which make it morphologically the most divergent within the M. natans group. This is also supported by the M. calcaratus specimens resolved as sister to the other three species clades on the COI and COI+28S trees. Merodon makrisi sp. nov. is morphologically similar to both M. natans and M. pulveris, while the latter two species are the most similar. Characters of antenna and male genitalia structure are the most stable features for delimiting M. natans, M. pulveris and M. makrisi sp. nov. Characters of the basoflagellomere are also very important for species delimitation.
The pattern of morphological relatedness between species of the M. natans group is supported on COI and COI+28S trees and in wing geometric morphometric analysis of M. calcaratus, M. pulveris and M. natans females, while in males M. calcaratus and M. natans have the most similar wing shape.
Despite their adult morphological resemblance, COI genetic distance between M. natans and M. pulveris is relatively high (5.1%) and similar to values between more distant species pairs (5.3–6.4%). The specimens of M. pulveris from Cyprus, based on COI and COI+28S analyses, segregate as reciprocally monophyletic within the M. pulveris clade. This population is morphologically indistinguishable from other analysed M. pulveris populations despite a genetic distance value of 2.2%, while the data on geometric morphometry is limited due to a small sample size. Previous studies documented genetic distances between morphologically cryptic Merodon species mostly in the range 0.3–2.5% (
The shared character of the three species of the Merodon natans group examined in our study is the presence of two different pairs of lappets on the anal segment, the dorsolateral pair being apically divided. This trait was also reported in two species of the avidus-nigritarsis lineage: M. avidus larva (
One of the most striking characters of the larva of M. pulveris is the possession of two sets of accessory teeth, a large pair on the basal outer side of the mandibular hooks and a small pair on the inner side of the hooks. Among all immature stages of Merodon species for which this character has been described, accessory teeth of the mandibular hooks were reported only for M. equestris and M. avidus larvae (
Shared characters of the three species examined in our study are the general shape and ornamentation of the posterior respiratory process (prp). The prp shape varies among Merodon species; for instance, very short cylinder (button-shaped) in M. avidus and M. opacus, barrel-shaped in M. calidus (puparium described as M. aureus in
One of the problems in the morphological research of Merodon immature stages is the difficulty of finding specimens in the field, since the larval food-plants and the breeding and oviposition sites have not been recorded for most Merodon species (
The four species of the Merodon natans group are mostly distributed within the Mediterranean Basin, but we report the first records of the presence of this species group in the Afrotropical Region, with the distributional range of two species reaching the easternmost parts of Sub-Saharan Africa. Merodon natans has been described geographically as a “Balkan” species, occurring throughout the Balkans and the eastern Mediterranean islands, except Dodecanese, North Aegean islands and Cyprus (
The regions with the highest diversity of Merodon taxa, such as the Mediterranean Basin, are characterized with flora rich in species of geophytes, as the bulbs and other underground storage organs of these plants are food sources for Merodon larvae (
Out of the four species of the Merodon natans group, descriptions of immature stages are presented for three species: M. pulveris based on larva, and M. natans and M. makrisi sp. nov. based on puparia, all found in the bulbs of the same plant species, Prospero autumnale. With the small size of one such bulb in mind, it could be speculated that these larvae grow at a slow rate, but it is possible that larvae move from one bulb to another while they grow, since P. autumnale can be found in dense patches. However, in the locality where the puparium of M. makrisi sp. nov. was found, the loamy soil can be very dried out and hard, making it seemingly difficult to move from one bulb to another. On the other hand, bulbs of P. autumnale are found quite superficially, making it possible for the larva to migrate to another bulb over the ground. This plant had previously been recorded as a possible larval host-plant for M. natans and M. pulveris in Greece (
AV, TT, XM, AvanE, SRad performed the sampling; AV, TT, SRad conceived and designed the study; AV, TT, AAnd, JA, LjŠZ, CP-B, AAra, SV, MA, XM performed the experimental analysis; AV, TT, AAnd, JA, LjŠZ, CP-B participated in data analyses. AV, TT, AAnd, JA, LjŠZ, CP-B, AAra, MA, XM, AvanE, SRoj took part in draft preparation, contributed to discussions during preparation of the paper, as well as read and commented on. All authors approved the final version of the manuscript.
We are sincerely grateful to Martin Ebejer (Wales, United Kingdom) and Antonio Ricarte (Alicante, Spain) for sharing photos of Merodon natans from Gibraltar and Spain, which helped a lot to understand the distribution of this species. Christodoulos Makris (Limassol, Cyprus) collected many specimens in Cyprus, shared information on flower visits and generously offered photos for this paper. The Department of Environment (ref. no’s 02.15.001.003 and 04.05.002.005.006) and the Department of Forests (ref. no. 2.15.05.3) of the Ministry of Agriculture, Rural Development and Environment of the Republic of Cyprus (Nicosia, Cyprus) kindly permitted us (AvE and XM) to collect in Cyprus. We thank Claudia Etzbauer (
File 1
Data type: .xlsx
Explanation note: Table S1. List of hoverfly specimens used for molecular and geometric morphometric analyses.
File 2
Data type: .pdf
Explanation note: Figure S1. Strict consensus tree of four equally parsimonious trees based on COI sequence analysis of Merodon natans species group. Filled circles stand for unique changes, open circles stand for non-unique changes; bootstrap values ≥ 50 are presented near nodes. Coloured sections indicate different Merodon lineages (yellow – aureus lineage, light green – desuturinus lineage, dark green – albifrons lineage, blue – avidus lineage, purple – natans lineage).
File 3
Data type: .pdf
Explanation note: Figure S2. Strict consensus tree of two equally parsimonious trees based on combined COI+28S rRNA gene sequence analysis of Merodon natans species group. Filled circles stand for unique changes, open circles stand for non-unique changes; bootstrap values ≥ 50 are presented near nodes. Coloured sections indicate different Merodon lineages (yellow – aureus lineage, light green – desuturinus lineage, dark green – albifrons lineage, blue – avidus lineage, purple – natans lineage).